S186 Constitutional/Law Check — Gate C and Current Roadmap

Date: 2026-04-28

Scope checked

Current work: Gate C seed 61 rows into 8 public.tac_* vocab/config tables, within Điều 38 Text-as-Code production rollout.

Laws / principles checked

• Hiến pháp / Constitutional First / User-gated production.
• Zero Trust / evidence-based execution.
• Điều 33 PostgreSQL law: PG as SSOT.
• Điều 38 Text-as-Code and LSL-01 information-unit-first.
• L1–L5 legal unlock: text unit, component/BOM, metadata, birth gate, unit review/change-set.
• Điều 24 label law: no label taxonomy mutation in Gate C.
• Điều 32 approval/change-set: not yet activating edit/change workflow; seed is governed gate DML.
• Điều 35 DOT governance: no DOT writes in Gate C.
• Điều 39 KG: KG/vector remains projection, not SSOT.
• Điều 43 context/system map: action logs and roadmap updates preserve state traceability.
• P9 Gate A/B/C separation and G8B/G11 separation.

Verdict

No blocking conflict found.

Gate C is constitutional/law-aligned if and only if it stays within the approved prompt scope:

• insert exactly 61 seed rows into 8 vocab/config tables;
• no DDL;
• no DELETE/TRUNCATE/UPDATE;
• no seed into six core/member tables;
• no Directus metadata changes;
• no roles/policies/permissions/tokens;
• no registry/birth/catalog/DOT writes;
• no corpus migration;
• stop after action log.

Key rationale

• PostgreSQL remains the source of truth.
• Seed files have KB source, manifest SHA, retargeted candidate SHA, and exact post-count verification.
• Directus is only a gateway/surface.
• KG/vector and Nuxt are later read/projection/render layers, not truth stores.
• User GO remains required for production mutation.

Residual guardrails

• Any mismatch in SHA, row counts, Gate A counts, or Gate B collection count must STOP.
• Any non-empty tac_* table before Gate C must STOP.
• Any scope expansion requires User decision.