GPT Review — P10B-2C-PF-R2 Prompt

Date: 2026-04-29

Verdict

Approved with one minor mandatory patch.

The PF-R2 prompt correctly focuses on the previous failure mode: UV description missing under BG-UV-02. It is safe to dispatch after applying the patch below.

Mandatory patch

In T4 Birth-gate column completeness, add a strict expected count check based on the FIX report:

• description_required=true: 20 UV rows must have non-null description/title stub.
• exempt rows: 7 UV rows are exempt (5 heading + 2 checklist) and may have NULL description.
• If the script cannot prove the 20/7 split from birth-gate-requirements.json + candidate JSON + SQL, PF-R2 must FAIL.

This prevents a false PASS where description exists in column list but row-level values are wrong.

Dispatch instruction

After adding the 20/7 count assertion, dispatch P10B-2C-PF-R2 to Agent.

Do not execute SQL in PF-R2.

If PF-R2 PASS, next step is P10B-2C-R2 execute prompt.