GPT Review — P10B-2B-FIX PASS + PF-R2 Direction

Date: 2026-04-29

Verdict

P10B-2B-FIX PASS confirmed.

The D28 package was regenerated correctly:

• Machine-readable birth-gate matrix produced.
• 8 blocking gates PASS.
• BG-UV-02 fixed by adding description = title stub where required.
• Candidate JSON unchanged.
• Only insert-candidate.sql changed.
• render/rollback/verify unchanged.
• Hardcode audit clean.
• No SQL executed.

Decision

Do not combine PF-R2 and execute.

Reason: the previous execute failed because PF did not check birth-gate-required columns. The fix must be independently inspected before mutation.

Direction to Opus

Draft P10B-2C-PF-R2 — D28 SQL Inspection after BG-UV-02 Fix.

PF-R2 must focus on what changed and what previously failed:

1. Verify file SHAs:

   • new insert-candidate.sql SHA 6dcab25c...
   • unchanged render/rollback/verify SHAs from P10B-2B.
   • candidate JSON SHA unchanged.

2. Inspect transaction structure:

   • outer BEGIN;
   • -- COMMIT; / -- ROLLBACK; decision lines commented.
   • safe COMMIT uncomment path.

3. Sanitized INSERT count:

   • publication = 1
   • LU = 27
   • UV = 27
   • PM = 27
   • total real rows = 82

4. Birth-gate column completeness:

   • UV INSERT column list includes description.
   • 27/27 UV rows have description expression/value.
   • rows with description_required=true use title stub.
   • heading/checklist exempt rows are acceptable if matrix proves exemption.
   • title, body, provenance, lifecycle_status, review_state still present.

5. Sample line-range inspection:

   • S0 paragraph: description present.
   • S3-P3 technical_spec: description present and $body$ body delimiter intact.
   • one heading unit: exemption documented.

6. Dollar-quoting safety:

   • no body contains literal $body$.
   • S3-P3 inner $$ remains inert.

7. Destructive command scan.

8. render/verify still self-scoped to DIEU-28 / v2.0.

9. Upload PF-R2 report and STOP.

Only after PF-R2 PASS should Opus draft/dispatch P10B-2C-R2 execute.