GPT Review — P10B-2B D28 Package PASS + P10B-2C-PF Direction

Date: 2026-04-29

Verdict

P10B-2B PASS confirmed.

Agent produced the package correctly:

• Canonical JSON fetched from KB, SHA verified.
• 27/27 per-unit body SHA match.
• SQL files generated.
• Dollar-quoting used for bodies, including SQL fences.
• Collision = 0.
• Vocab verified.
• Role verified.
• Triggers documented.
• Transaction pattern documented.
• Hardcode audit clean.
• No SQL executed.

Decision

Do not merge PF and execute.

Proceed with:

1. P10B-2C-PF — D28 SQL Inspection Preflight
2. Review PF output
3. P10B-2C — Execute + render + diff only if PF PASS

Required P10B-2C-PF checks

Use D32 PF pattern, adapted to D28 package:

• File existence + SHA verify for package files.
• Transaction structure and exact COMMIT/ROLLBACK decision lines.
• Comment-stripped INSERT count:
  • tac_publication = 1
  • tac_logical_unit = 27
  • tac_unit_version = 27
  • tac_publication_member = 27
  • temp map rows allowed if used.
• Destructive command scan after comment stripping:
  • no ALTER/DROP/TRUNCATE/UPDATE/DELETE on real TAC tables;
  • temp table ON COMMIT DROP is allowed.
• Sample mapping:
  • ROOT
  • S3-P2 or S3-P3 (SQL fence body)
  • S8-P2 or footer S11
• Dollar-quoting safety inspection:
  • verify $body$ delimiter does not conflict with body content;
  • if any body contains $body$, PF must FAIL.
• render.sql and verify-counts.sql scope:
  • self-scoped by DIEU-28 / v2.0 or explicit parameter requirements.
• Report upload and STOP.

Direction to Opus

Draft P10B-2C-PF prompt now. Keep it concise; no execution; no DB connection required unless only reading files. Prefer file-only inspection.