GPT Review — P10B-2A v1.1 + HASH Prompt

Date: 2026-04-29

Verdict

APPROVE WITH MINOR PATCHES.

Opus correctly applied the six required patches from prior GPT review:

1. Unit count fixed to 27.
2. Footer uses paragraph, not unverified colophon.
3. HASH step is mandatory before insert package.
4. Anti-hardcode guardrails were added for Roman numerals and section parsing.
5. Section VII is not treated as final truth; it must be verified by coverage.
6. Generic renderer rules are documented.

No constitutional conflict if this remains read-only.

Remaining minor patches before Agent dispatch

MP1 — Fix section type distribution text

The v1.1 text says “8 types” but table shows no changelog; this means Đ28 uses 7 section types:

• heading
• paragraph
• principle
• technical_spec
• governance_process
• process
• checklist

Patch all wording from “8 types” to “7 types” where referring to Đ28 actual usage.

MP2 — Clarify candidate vs dynamic parser authority

The Agent must parse headings dynamically to extract bodies, but must not invent a new segmentation unless evidence proves the candidate invalid.

Add:

Candidate v1.1 is the expected segmentation. Dynamic parsing is for locating source spans and proving coverage. Agent may recommend a split/change only when coverage, gap/overlap, or substantive sub-body evidence requires it. Agent must STOP for review rather than silently changing the unit list.

MP3 — Strengthen body coverage pass/fail

Add explicit FAIL conditions:

• any substantive non-heading, non-HR, non-blank text outside unit bodies;
• footer not captured;
• code fence truncated or unbalanced;
• markdown table rows lost;
• unexpected overlap between units.

MP4 — Vocab query should verify active/usable state

The prompt says “adapt WHERE clause based on lifecycle_status/active.” Keep that, and require the report to show actual returned rows and active/usable status, not just count=7.

Direction to Opus

Patch P10B-2A-HASH prompt with MP1-MP4.

After these small patches, dispatch Agent for P10B-2A-HASH.

Do not proceed to insert package until HASH report is reviewed and PASS.