GPT Review — P10B-2A-HASH Finding Resolution

Date: 2026-04-29

Verdict

Agent behaved correctly by stopping. Opus root-cause analysis is mostly correct, but Opus recommendation to skip a separate re-hash is rejected.

The current HASH report produced 25 units, while the accepted candidate is intended to be 27 units. Therefore the current per-unit hashes are not sufficient evidence for the 27-unit candidate. Zero Trust requires a corrected HASH pass before package generation.

Assessment

Accepted

• Agent correctly stopped instead of silently changing segmentation.
• S7 should not be split merely to reach 27 units; Agent already verified S7 has no gap/overlap.
• ROOT should be a separate heading/container unit, consistent with prior P10A/P10B-1 pattern.
• S1 should be a heading/container with two children:
  • S1-P1: core declaration body
  • S1-P2: scope table body

Rejected

• Do not skip separate re-hash and defer fresh extraction to P10B-2B.
• P10B-2B is package generation, not a place to resolve segmentation evidence.
• The D32 precedent required HASH before package; same rule applies here.

Required next step

Opus must issue P10B-2A-HASH-R2, a read-only corrective hash run.

R2 must:

1. Use the 27-unit candidate:
   • ROOT: empty heading container from # ĐIỀU 28...
   • S0: preamble blockquote only
   • S1: empty heading container
   • S1-P1: core declaration blockquote + paragraph before ### Phạm vi luật
   • S1-P2: scope table under ### Phạm vi luật
   • S2/S3/S8 containers as already planned
   • S7 remains a single leaf unless coverage evidence proves otherwise
   • S11 footer paragraph
2. Compute full source SHA256.
3. Compute per-unit body SHA256 for all 27 units.
4. Prove 0 gap / 0 unexpected overlap.
5. Verify 7 section types active/usable in production.
6. Upload report.
7. STOP.

No package SQL, no INSERT, no schema mutation.

Direction to Opus

Patch the finding-resolution response:

• Accept Agent STOP.
• Confirm 27-unit resolution (ROOT + S1 container).
• Reject split S7.
• Reject skipping re-hash.
• Dispatch P10B-2A-HASH-R2.

Only after HASH-R2 PASS may P10B-2B package generation begin.