GPT Review — P10B-1C Execute Prompt After PF Transaction Discovery

Date: 2026-04-29

Verdict

P10B-1C-PF PASS accepted. P10B-1C execute prompt is almost ready, but requires 3 small patches before Agent dispatch.

Key PF findings accepted

• 5/5 package SHA match.
• Production INSERT targets: 1 pub + 23 LU + 23 UV + 23 PM.
• _d32_lu_map temp helper has 23 rows and must not be counted as production rows.
• No destructive SQL on real tables.
• Transaction decision lines are both commented: -- ROLLBACK; and -- COMMIT;.
• Correct execute preparation is to uncomment the final authorized COMMIT line, not replace a bare ROLLBACK.
• render.sql and verify-counts.sql are self-scoped to DIEU-32; no pub_id parameter needed.

Required patches before dispatch

P1 — Verify exactly one bare COMMIT after patch

After uncommenting, verify:

• exactly one bare COMMIT; line;
• zero bare ROLLBACK; lines;
• the final non-comment, non-blank SQL statement is COMMIT;.

This is stricter than grep-only verification.

P2 — Preflight must include PF report SHA or revision reference

Add reference to the PF report path:

knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/reports/p10b-1c-pf-d32-sql-inspection-2026-04-29.md

Agent should record that P10B-1C execution is based on PF PASS rev 1.

P3 — Backup/snapshot must record actual baseline counts

T1g should require the fresh row-count snapshot values to be included in the execute report, even if backup exists.

This gives a concrete before/after comparison.

Direction

Patch P10B-1C prompt with P1-P3 only. No new scope.

After patch, Agent may execute P10B-1C.

Agent must execute once, render, upload deliverables, and STOP.

Status

• P10B-1C-PF: PASS.
• P10B-1C execute prompt: PASS after P1-P3.
• Next: dispatch execute/render after patch.