GPT Review — P10B-1B D32 Package PASS and P10B-1C Directive

Date: 2026-04-29

Verdict

P10B-1B: PASS.

The read-only package generation completed successfully and meets the guardrails set after the hardcode incident.

Do not execute yet. Opus must draft a separate P10B-1C execution prompt for final review.

Accepted evidence

• Source SHA verified: a42622496fff8c725932a5d310d1e4050e63e41828ba01c1eec4974c045e17f7.
• candidate-units.json: 23 units, full body, 23/23 body hashes match.
• Schema discovery: 54 columns across 4 target tables.
• Collision: publication=0, LU=0.
• Vocab: all required vocab families verified.
• Role: directus has INSERT on all 4 target tables.
• Triggers: 6 documented; BG-UV-02 block handled via description stub.
• SQL files generated from JSON and hashed.
• Generator scripts retained and hashed.
• Hardcode audit: PASS, no enumerated unit arrays in generation logic.
• No production mutation.

Decisions on five points

D1 — description = title stub

ACCEPT FOR MVP.

This is conservative and satisfies BG-UV-02. It is acceptable for P10B. Record follow-up for richer Đ43-style descriptions.

D2 — risk_tier = medium

ACCEPT FOR MVP if the value is valid under production CHECK/vocab and was generated by the package. Do not change in execution prompt unless schema check fails.

D3 — owner = incomex_council

ACCEPT FOR MVP if the value satisfies the current schema/check constraints. Record follow-up for canonical owner registry if needed.

D4 — ROLLBACK → COMMIT

ACCEPT ONLY IN P10B-1C execution prompt after fresh preflight and SHA verification.

The execution prompt must copy the package to a run-specific file, replace final ROLLBACK; with COMMIT;, verify the run-file SHA after replacement, and keep the original package file unchanged.

D5 — doc_registry gate

No blocker found in P10B-1B evidence.

Proceed, but P10B-1C preflight must still re-check triggers/gates status and stop on drift.

Required P10B-1C execution prompt guardrails

Opus should draft P10B-1C — D32 Execute + Render v0.1.

Scope:

• execute approved package for DIEU-32 only;
• render clean human-readable markdown;
• diff against original;
• upload deliverables;
• STOP.

Required guardrails:

1. Fresh preflight:

   • current DB/user;
   • schema count unchanged;
   • triggers enabled;
   • collisions still 0;
   • source SHA match;
   • candidate JSON SHA match;
   • SQL package SHAs match P10B-1B report;
   • backup/snapshot evidence.

2. Do not edit original package SQL in place:

   • copy insert-candidate.sql to /tmp/p10b-1c-d32-insert-run.sql;
   • replace final ROLLBACK; with COMMIT; only in run file;
   • confirm original still ends with ROLLBACK;;
   • confirm run file ends with COMMIT;.

3. Execute once:

   • psql -v ON_ERROR_STOP=1 -X;
   • capture output log;
   • extract pub_id UUID robustly;
   • verify pub_id exists.

4. Post-commit verification:

   • expected 1 publication + 23 LU + 23 UV + 23 PM;
   • lifecycle mutable: publication proposed, UV draft;
   • no enacted.
   • If mismatch after commit: STOP + report IDs; do not auto-rollback.

5. Render:

   • run approved render SQL;
   • save raw TSV;
   • convert to clean markdown;
   • skip synthetic root and placeholder bodies;
   • preserve human-readable text.

6. Diff and deliverables:

   • original.md;
   • reconstructed-clean.md;
   • diff-report.md;
   • tree-report.md;
   • row-count-report.md;
   • rollback-instructions.md;
   • execute report.

7. Hard exclusions:

   • no DDL;
   • no seed/role/permission/token changes;
   • no Nuxt/KG/vector;
   • no broad migration;
   • no lifecycle promotion to enacted;
   • no auto-rollback after committed mismatch.

Status

• P10B-1A: PASS.
• P10B-1A-HASH: PASS.
• P10B-1B package: PASS.
• Next: Opus drafts P10B-1C execution prompt for review.
• Execution is not yet authorized until P10B-1C prompt is reviewed.