GPT Review — P10A-1 Dispatch Prompt R5 and Git Commit Disagreement

Date: 2026-04-29

Verdict

APPROVE WITH ONE MICRO-PATCH.

Opus is mostly correct, but the GIT COMMIT rule must be narrowed. Điều 41 does not mean every read-only evidence task must create or commit repository changes. It means if code/ops files are changed on the VPS, those changes must have audit trail / commit or snapshot discipline.

Assessment of Opus disagreement on Patch #3

What Opus got right

Opus is right that Điều 41 is active and VPS is an operational SSOT for code/ops work. If P10A-1 creates or modifies persistent files inside a tracked VPS repo, the agent should not leave untracked/uncommitted drift.

What needs correction

Opus overextends the rule by keeping a blanket GIT COMMIT requirement for P10A-1.

P10A-1's canonical output is an Agent Data KB report. If the agent only creates temp files or uploads a KB report through Agent Data, there may be no repo change to commit. Forcing a git commit in that case can create meaningless commits or encourage writing files to a repo just to satisfy the prompt.

Required wording patch

Replace:

GIT COMMIT local files nếu có tạo trên VPS (VPS = code SSOT, Đ41).

With:

Đ41 / VPS code hygiene: Run git status in any repo touched. If P10A-1 intentionally creates or modifies persistent tracked repo files, commit them with a clear message or record why no commit is needed. If only temp files are created and the canonical output is uploaded to Agent Data KB, no git commit is required; log temp paths/SHA and cleanup status. Do not create repo files solely to satisfy a commit requirement.

Other patches accepted

• Header changed to draft pending GPT PASS + User GO.
• Vocab table names corrected to _vocab and production verification required.
• DB/role verification added via SELECT current_database(), current_user.
• PASS criteria refined for all 14 column snapshot plus detailed discovery for relevant tables.

Law / constitutional check

No blocking conflict after the git wording patch.

• Hiến pháp / Zero Trust: aligned. Facts are verified before use.
• Điều 38 / LSL-01: aligned. Segmentation candidate only.
• Điều 33: aligned. No production data mutation.
• Điều 41: aligned with narrowed wording: commit/snapshot applies when repo files are actually changed.
• Gate separation: aligned. No P10A-2 insert/render.

Directive to Opus 4.6

Apply the single wording patch above. Do not rewrite the prompt.

After patch, return the final P10A-1 dispatch prompt for GPT final review or mark it as ready if no other text changed.

No Agent dispatch until GPT PASS + User GO.

Current state

• P10A-1 prompt: ready after one git wording micro-patch.
• P10A-1 execution: not authorized yet.
• P10A-2 insert/render: not authorized.