GPT Review — G6 Retry Dispatch v0.4 Docker Exec

Date: 2026-04-27
Scope: Review Opus G6 RETRY DISPATCH v0.4 — DOCKER EXEC prompt.

Verdict

PASS WITH SMALL REQUIRED EDITS BEFORE DISPATCH.

The v0.4 wrapper correctly aborts the over-engineered GSM branch and uses the established Docker-local Postgres path. This is simpler, more evidence-based, and better aligned with the actual VPS runtime.

Evidence checked

• knowledge/dev/reports/gpt-correction-g6-db-connection-simplify-2026-04-27.md — correction to use Docker-local connection.
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/reports/p9-g6-execution-log-2026-04-27.md — run #1 hard-stop before DDL.
• Agent Data prior ops evidence: S178/Đ43 notes show -U directus is the valid PG user; S174 backup report references the postgres container.

Law / constitutional check

Rule	Result	Finding
Hiến pháp / Zero Trust	PASS with edits	Uses observed runtime path; still must fail-stop on container/permission mismatch.
100% DOT/AI	PASS	User is not asked to fetch secrets.
Đ33 DB governance	PASS	Isolated schema only; no production business schema mutation.
Đ35 DOT governance	PASS	No dot_tools/dot_action_log mutation.
Đ32 gate discipline	PASS	Retry remains gated by User authorization.
Đ24	PASS	No taxonomy/entity label mutation.

Required edits

1. Authorization wording
   User authorize: PENDING is correct. Keep it until User explicitly authorizes retry.

2. Container check must be exact
   Replace docker ps --filter name=postgres with an exact check to avoid matching postgres-test or stale containers:

   docker inspect -f '{{.State.Running}}' postgres
   

   Expected output: true. If not true, STOP.

3. CREATE privilege test should assert result
   Current DO block only PERFORMs and may not assert false. Use a query that returns t, or a DO block that raises on false:

   SELECT has_database_privilege('directus','directus','CREATE') AS can_create_schema;
   

   Expected: t. If false, STOP.

4. Do not disable all .env use globally
   Disable .env only for DB credentials. Keep any non-DB env use required by the original prompt/report tooling if needed. Wording: “DB credential env vars are not required for psql; do not use .env for DB connection.”

5. Directus API checks from prompt v0.2
   If the original prompt still requires Directus API checks for FAC/DOT counts, v0.4 must specify how to handle them: either use already available agent-data/Directus MCP read-only path, or if token/env is unavailable, record N/A with evidence and rely on prior E6/E7 evidence. Do not re-open GSM just for Directus token unless separately needed. DB dry-run should not be blocked by Directus token if DB pre-flight and prior KB evidence cover FAC/DOT readiness.

6. Action log should be append/new revision
   The path p9-g6-execution-log-2026-04-27.md already contains run #1. Retry should either update the same document with a new “Run #2” section or create a run-specific log path such as p9-g6-execution-log-run2-2026-04-27.md and link both. Avoid overwriting run #1 evidence.

Direction

Apply the edits above, then dispatch to Codex with xhigh/max effort. This wrapper authorizes retry only if the User explicitly says AUTHORIZE. If Codex runs, it must preserve all original hard exclusions and stop after uploading the action log.