GPT Review — G6 Finalization PASS / Ready for Execution Authorization

Date: 2026-04-27
Scope: Review Opus finalization block after GPT R4 for G6 execution prompt.

Verdict

PASS. G6 finalization is complete. Ready to present final execution authorization request.

This PASS does not itself execute G6. It authorizes Opus to present the final execution-gate request to User/GPT.

Evidence checked

• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/P9-G6-execution-prompt.md rev 1 — OFFICIAL v0.2, full content persisted in KB, content length ~51KB.
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/P9-G6-precedence-errata.md rev 1 — precedence note resolving package/prompt PF-01 conflict.
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/seed-manifest-g6-expected.json rev 1 — manifest with 8 files, total_seed_rows=61, hash_status=PENDING_COMPUTE.
• 8 seed files under knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/seed-g6/ rev 1 each.
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/index.md rev 1 — G6 prompt OFFICIAL, finalization complete.

Findings

1. Full prompt persistence: PASS. The durable KB source-of-truth now contains the full v0.2 execution prompt, not only a summary.
2. PF-01 errata/precedence: PASS. Prompt v0.2 supersedes package v0.2 PF-01 wording; pre-existing schema = STOP, not auto-DROP.
3. Seed canonical files: PASS. 8/8 files exist with row semantics matching 61 total seed rows.
4. Seed manifest: PASS with explicit condition. hash_status=PENDING_COMPUTE is acceptable because Opus honestly cannot compute hashes in Desktop context. First execution must compute SHA-256 via sha256sum, record it in the action log, and later update the manifest for subsequent runs. The agent must not pretend the expected hash was precomputed.
5. Index/status: PASS. S184 tracking reflects prompt OFFICIAL v0.2 and finalization complete.
6. No execution performed: PASS. All work was KB/document-only.

Law / constitutional check

Rule	Result	Finding
Hiến pháp / Zero Trust	PASS	Full source-of-truth persisted; hash limitation is explicitly disclosed rather than faked.
Đ33 DB governance	PASS	No DDL/DML executed; future G6 remains isolated schema only.
Đ35 DOT governance	PASS	No dot_tools/dot_action_log mutation; markdown report only.
Đ32 approval discipline	PASS	Execution still requires explicit authorization.
Đ24	PASS	No taxonomy/entity label mutation.
S183 anti-patterns	PASS	No auto-drop, no hardcoded DB user, no extension creation, source-of-truth durable in KB.

Condition for execution gate

When opening G6 execution gate, include this condition:

• Because seed-manifest-g6-expected.json has hash_status=PENDING_COMPUTE, the first G6 execution must compute SHA-256 for the 8 canonical seed files, record all hashes in the action log, verify semantic row counts and code lists against the manifest, and STOP if file contents differ from KB seed files. After execution, Opus should update the manifest with computed hashes as a documentation update only.

Direction

Opus may now present a final G6 execution authorization request. The request must be concise and explicit:

• Use P9-G6-execution-prompt.md OFFICIAL v0.2.
• Run only on isolated schema p9_g6_dryrun.
• Execute by Claude CLI/Claude Code agent on VPS.
• No production public.tac_*, no Directus role/permission mutation, no taxonomy/entity labels, no system_issues, no dot_action_log, no CREATE EXTENSION.
• If any pre-flight fails, STOP.
• After verification, rollback DROP SCHEMA p9_g6_dryrun CASCADE, verify residue=0, upload action log, STOP.

No further broad design review is required before asking for execution authorization.