GPT Review — E4 APR FAC-07/08/09 v0.2 Final

Date: 2026-04-27
Scope: Review Opus E4 v0.2 patch in knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/P9-e4-apr-request-fac-07-08-09.md after GPT scope-boundary finding.

Verdict

PASS. No blocker found for E4 as a doc/APR package.

E4 v0.2 correctly resolves the prior governance mismatch. The APR package is now explicitly facet-only: it requests three taxonomy_facets candidates and excludes taxonomy_labels and entity_labels from E4/E5 scope.

Evidence checked

• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/P9-e4-apr-request-fac-07-08-09.md rev 2 — E4 v0.2 with §3 “Facets Only”, §7 E5 scope only approved taxonomy facets, §8 scope boundary.
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/P8-implementation-design-plan-v0-1.md — P8 v0.4 §5.1/§5.3/§5.4: aliases, candidate facets, governed APR/DOT/API flow, entity_labels-only rule.
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/P8-s5-amendment-e-e3.md — E-E3 APPLIED; FAC-07/08/09 candidate pending APR.
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/P9-tier2-remediation-design.md — R1 governed taxonomy addition, no direct seed; E4→E5 sequencing.

Law / constitutional check

Rule	Result	Finding
Hiến pháp / 100% DOT	PASS	No manual DB/UI mutation. E5 still requires governed DOT/API prompt and approval.
Đ24 label governance	PASS	Labels/entity_labels are explicitly excluded from E4/E5 facet-only scope.
Đ32 APR	PASS	APR scope now matches proposed mutation: taxonomy_facets only.
Đ33 Directus/API	PASS	Future E5 specifies Directus API path, not manual SQL.
Đ35 DOT governance	PASS	DOT-TAC-LABEL-SYNC remains execution path only if approved/authorized.
P8 v0.4 §5	PASS	FAC-07/08/09 remain candidates; production identity depends on APR outcome.

Residual constraints

• This PASS does not approve facet creation.
• This PASS does not authorize APR record creation unless User/Council opens that gate.
• This PASS does not authorize taxonomy_labels or entity_labels writes.
• E5 must be separately scoped to the approved APR outcome only.

Direction

Proceed to the next governance step: prepare the APR decision/submission gate for FAC-07/FAC-08/FAC-09 facet candidates. Do not run E5/E7/P9. Do not create facets or labels. If APR is approved/modified/rejected, update downstream plan and P8 §5 mapping accordingly.