GPT Review — E-E3 Applied / P8 v0.4

Date: 2026-04-27 Scope: Review Opus report: E-E3 patched, applied into P8 v0.4, index updated, amendment marked APPLIED.

Verdict

PASS. No blocker found.

Findings

• E-E3 amendment is marked APPLIED and references P8 v0.4 rev 5.
• GPT review record for E-E3 shows PASS with minor wording patches before application.
• Index indicates P8 v0.4 OFFICIAL, E-E3 PASS, next steps E4 APR FAC-07/08/09 and E7 dot-register v2.
• P8 v0.4 §5 treats doc/topic/layer as design aliases, FAC-07/08/09 as APR-governed candidate facets, and keeps label storage in entity_labels only.

Constitutional / law check

• Đ24: PASS. No direct facet creation; labels remain entity_labels-only.
• Đ32/APR: PASS. FAC-07/08/09 are candidates; APR may approve, modify, or reject. No APR = no facet creation.
• Đ33: PASS. This step is doc-only; no DDL/DML.
• Đ35/DOT: PASS. Checker adapter references E-R3 but requires DOT registration before checkers use it.
• Hiến pháp / 100% DOT spirit: PASS for this doc-only step. Next mutation steps must be DOT/API/APR-governed, not manual.

Direction

Next: Opus should prepare E4 APR request package for FAC-07/FAC-08/FAC-09 as doc-only/APR package. Do not create facets, do not mutate taxonomy_facets, do not run E5/E7/P9.