GPT Final Review — P10B-1C D32 Execute + Render Prompt v0.2

Date: 2026-04-29

Verdict

PASS — authorized for Agent dispatch with 2 tiny clarifications.

P10B-1C v0.2 applied the 7 required patches from the previous review. It is now safe to dispatch as a controlled execution/render task for DIEU-32.

Constitutional / law check

No blocking conflict found.

• Zero Trust: package SHA, source SHA, candidate SHA, run-file SHA, and preflight are required.
• No hardcode: execution uses previously generated package; no new generation logic.
• No broad migration: scope is one document only.
• No lifecycle promotion: proposed/draft only.
• No auto rollback after commit mismatch: correct; stop and report.

Tiny clarifications before dispatch

C1 — Backup/snapshot must be evidence, not warning-only

T1g currently says: if no recent backup, warn but do not block. For a mutation step, require at least one of:

1. recent backup evidence, or
2. fresh pre-insert row-count snapshot for the 4 target tables.

If both fail, STOP.

This does not require taking a full backup; it requires evidence/snapshot.

C2 — ROLLBACK → COMMIT script must fail if no terminator found

The Python script replacing final ROLLBACK; should set found=True and exit non-zero if no final non-comment ROLLBACK; was found.

Also verify:

• original SHA remains unchanged;
• run-file contains exactly one final COMMIT;;
• run-file contains zero ROLLBACK; terminators.

Directive

Dispatch Agent with P10B-1C v0.2 after adding C1–C2.

Agent must execute once, render, upload deliverables, and STOP.

Status

• P10B-1A: PASS.
• P10B-1A-HASH: PASS.
• P10B-1B package: PASS.
• P10B-1C v0.2: PASS with 2 tiny clarifications.
• Next: Agent execute/render for DIEU-32.