Incomex AI Portal
KB-1B79

GPT Decision S190 — P10B COMPLETE confirmed, S188 closeout direction

5 min read Revision 1
s190s188p10bcompleted28closeoutp10dgpt-decision

GPT Decision S190 — P10B COMPLETE confirmed, S188 closeout direction

Date: 2026-04-30
Phase: TAC MVP / P10B
Decision: P10B COMPLETE confirmed. S188 closeout approved.

1. Evidence read / checked

Read directly:

  • knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/reports/p10b-2c-r2-followup-d28-2026-04-30.md
  • knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/reports/p10b-2c-r2-d28-execute-report-2026-04-30.md

Checked prior PASS evidence via KB search / existing GPT decisions:

  • knowledge/dev/reports/gpt-review-p10b-1c-d32-pass-and-next-direction-2026-04-29.md
  • Handoff/roadmap evidence for P10A D35 PASS.

2. D28 confirmation

D28 P10B-2 is accepted as PASS.

Confirmed from follow-up report:

  • Gate 0 SSH VPS PASS: runtime DB identity directus/directus.
  • Publication: cf8d4dc0-3d70-55f8-8c35-e01da101d710, DIEU-28/v2.0, lifecycle proposed.
  • Counts: pub=1, LU=27, UV=27, PM=27.
  • BG-UV-02 live: has_desc=20, null_desc=7.
  • Corrected lifecycle query: UV draft=27.
  • Render produced 27 rows.
  • Normalized diff: IDENTICAL, 0 content drift.
  • Tree report: 27 rows, render order 0..26.
  • Deliverables uploaded through Agent Data API.
  • No rollback executed.
  • P10B was not closed out by Agent, as required.

The unified diff only showed final newline difference; normalized content drift is 0.

3. P10B complete confirmation

P10B multi-document validation is accepted as COMPLETE.

Validated documents:

Document Units Result
D35 v5.2 / P10A 36 PASS, 0 content drift
D32 v1.1 / P10B-1 23 PASS, 0 content drift
D28 v2.0 / P10B-2 27 PASS, 0 content drift

Total validated units: 86.

This proves TAC MVP round-trip across:

  • large law document;
  • smaller law document;
  • medium document with Roman numerals, SQL/PLpgSQL code fences, tables, footer, and birth-gate-sensitive descriptions.

4. Law / constitution check

No conflict found with current constraints:

  • VPS remained runtime/DB SSOT; access was through verified SSH.
  • KB remained artifact/report SSOT.
  • /tmp was treated as ephemeral workspace only.
  • KB uploads used Agent Data API, not direct SQL against kb_documents.
  • No unauthorized rollback was executed.
  • D28 mutation was gated by REGEN-PROMOTE, PF-R2, Execute R2, and read-only follow-up.
  • Known failure modes generated permanent guardrails: manifest/read-back, SSH Gate 0, birth-gate matrix, PF before execute, qualified SQL checks, flow-control markers.

Note: D28 clean render used one flagged D28-specific renderer rule. This is acceptable for MVP validation/reporting but must become a design input for P10D; production UI renderer must avoid hidden hardcoded section-specific behavior.

5. Direction to Opus

S188 closeout is approved.

Opus should perform a concise closeout, not another technical loop:

  1. Write S188 → S189 handoff to KB.
  2. State P10B COMPLETE with links to the final D28 execute/follow-up reports and prior D32/D35 PASS evidence.
  3. Record lessons as operating guardrails:
    • /tmp is not inter-machine SSOT;
    • Mac Agent → SSH VPS is valid control path, VPS remains runtime SSOT;
    • birth-gate compliance matrix required before execute package;
    • PF inspection required before execute;
    • KB manifest + read-back required for cross-machine artifacts;
    • prompt SQL must qualify ambiguous columns;
    • flow-control marker pattern worked and should remain.
  4. Set next target: P10D design note / Nuxt Laws Page UX and architecture.
  5. Do not start implementing P10D in this closeout.

6. P10D direction for next session

Next session should start with P10D design note only, not implementation.

Initial P10D scope:

  • /knowledge/laws route reused;
  • left tree view, right reader;
  • clean reader mode by default;
  • admin/reviewer unit-boundary overlay toggle;
  • optional debug mode;
  • stable unit IDs vs structural position vs human numbering;
  • renderer must be generic and avoid hidden D28/D32/D35-specific case-dispatch;
  • document object final layer can become its own enriched DB over time;
  • production requirements still need User input before implementation workflow.

7. Final status

P10B COMPLETE. S188 closeout approved. P10D is next, deferred to S189 / next session.