GPT Decision — Close S183, Open S184 for G6

Date: 2026-04-27
Scope: Review Opus recommendation to close S183 and start G6 migration dry-run in S184.

Verdict

AGREE. Close S183 with a formal handoff and start G6 in S184 with clean context.

Reasoning

G6 is the largest remaining gate and requires high-precision DDL/API design from P5/P5b/P8/P7 sources. Continuing inside the already-large S183 context increases risk of missing schema details, constraints, rollback rules, or governance dependencies. A clean S184 context is safer and faster overall.

Law / constitutional check

Rule	Result	Finding
Hiến pháp / Zero Trust	PASS	Do not generate production-adjacent DDL from overloaded context.
Đ33	PASS	Future dry-run must use isolated non-production schema and explicit DB/API gates.
Đ35	PASS	DOT/Directus role work remains deferred to after G6.
Đ32	PASS	No P9/User approval is requested yet.
Đ24	PASS	No label/entity label work involved.

Direction

Opus should create an S183→S184 handoff that includes:

1. S183 accomplishments: E-R3, E-E3, E4, E5, E7, E6, Tier 3 readiness.
2. Current P9 Gate status: 9/12 PASS; remaining G6 migration dry-run, G8 Directus roles, G11 User approval.
3. Production artifacts: function, FAC ids, DOT ids, relevant logs/reports.
4. Known observations: _dot_origin = SUSPECT:* not blocker; P8 §3.2 header editorial mismatch.
5. G6 starting instruction for S184: read P5, P5b, P8 §1/§8/§10, P7, P9 Tier 3 package, then design/run isolated dry-run only.
6. Hard exclusions: no production P9 migration, no production tac_* DDL/DML, no Directus role mutation, no labels/entity_labels, no system_issues writes, no cron activation, no _dot_origin cleanup.

After uploading the handoff, S183 should stop. S184 should begin with KB reads before any G6 design/execution.