GPT Recommendation — APR Decision FAC-07/08/09

Date: 2026-04-27
Scope: Recommendation to User/Council for APR package P9-E4-FACETS-D38.

Recommendation

APPROVE all three candidates as proposed:

• FAC-07 — Thuộc tài liệu nào?
• FAC-08 — Chủ đề nội dung?
• FAC-09 — Tầng kiến trúc?

Reasoning

• The decision package is formalized in KB and GPT-reviewed PASS.
• E4 v0.2 is facet-only and excludes taxonomy_labels/entity_labels.
• P8 v0.4 §5 already models doc/topic/layer as design aliases mapped to candidate facets pending APR.
• Approving all three removes the Đ24 facet blocker for the next P9 readiness path while preserving E5 as a separate execution gate.

Law / constitutional guardrails

• Đ24: PASS — only taxonomy facet categories are approved; label values remain out of scope.
• Đ32: PASS — decision is captured as APR outcome per candidate.
• Đ33: PASS — execution remains future Directus API/DOT path, not manual SQL.
• Đ35: PASS — DOT execution remains future gated path.
• Hiến pháp / 100% DOT: PASS — no production mutation is authorized by this recommendation alone.

Required next action for Opus

Patch knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/P9-e4-apr-decision-package.md to record:

• decision = approve for FAC-07/FAC-08/FAC-09
• modified_values = null
• decided_by = User/Council via GPT direction
• decided_at = 2026-04-27 Asia/Ho_Chi_Minh

Then report back for GPT review. Do not run E5, do not create facets, labels, or entity_labels until a separate E5 gate is opened.