KB-6DAB
T1-Max Review - Direct Revisions Applied
5 min read Revision 1
fix7architecturemax-reviewdirect-revisions
11 - SUPERTRACK L: Direct Revisions Applied to the Blueprint
Every patch this Max pass made, with the old issue, the correction, cross-impact, affected packages/guards, and whether XHigh's prior conclusion changed. No duplicate docs were created; existing docs were patched in place. Production stayed READ-ONLY throughout.
| id | sev | blueprint doc(s) patched | old issue | correction | affected pkg/guard | XHigh conclusion changed? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| MA-01 | P2 | 00 (rev 2), 12 (rev 6), checkpoint (rev 5) | post-XHigh top-line status still ..._READY_FOR_CODEX_CRITICAL_REVIEW (skipped Max gate) |
advanced to ..._MAX_REVIEWED_AND_REVISED_READY_FOR_CODEX_CRITICAL_REVIEW + gate-progression note + Max-pass section |
none | no - XHigh status itself was correct; only the blueprint's stale carriers were fixed |
| MB-01 | P1 | 01 (rev 3), 02 (rev 5), 04 (rev 11/12/13), 05 (rev 6), 06 (rev 7), 07 (rev 9/10) | legacy neutralization scoped to "apply/writer" (adjective), not the complete set; live: ALL 46 fns PUBLIC-executable | S00 captures the COMPLETE catalog-derived legacy set; S15/PKG-F REVOKE the whole set; G-NOLEGACY verifies non-owner-executable=0 over it; closes S15->S17 window | PKG-F, S15/S16/S17; G-NOLEGACY | strengthens XHB-02/XH-2 (no reversal) - "blocked, not merely unreachable" now over the complete set |
| MB-02 | P3 | 01 (rev 3) | birth-family listed 5 of 10 live fn_birth_*; no trigger-vector evidence |
recorded all 10 (all DO_NOT_TOUCH) + 0-trigger bypass-vector evidence | none (DO_NOT_TOUCH) | no |
| MC-01 | P1 | 06 (rev 8), 08 (rev 5) | G-DOT-NOOVERWRITE led with "DOT bodies" - risked source-text as final authority | PG-native owner-isolation = final authority; DOT-body scan = fail-closed diagnostic; birth-gateway = detection+freeze+policy | G-DOT-NOOVERWRITE; PKG-E/I | strengthens XHB-01 (no reversal) |
| MD-01 | (folded) | 04 (rev 13), 05 (rev 7) | mixed-authority window + gateway-overwrite-on-rollback not explicit | S15/S16 atomic + guard-verified end state; rollback restores pinned source (never CREATE OR REPLACE); G-BIRTH-NEUTRAL re-check | S15/S16; G-BIRTH-NEUTRAL | strengthens XHB-02 |
| ME-01 | P2 | 05 (rev 5), 07 (rev 11/12) | ACL rollback snapshot not enumerated (concreteness gap) | snapshot = ownership + table/view/function/sequence ACLs + schema nspacl + default privileges | PKG-G; G-OWNER-CUTOVER | extends MX-3 (no reversal) |
| MG-01 | P2 | 07 (rev 13/14) | no fresh Codex re-audit before PKG-F/PKG-G (the governance-change packages) | re-audit + permit gate added before PKG-F and PKG-G; sequencing diagram updated (law §4G) | PKG-F, PKG-G | no - tightens the existing gate chain |
| MH-01 | P2 | 06 (rev 9/10) | guard-quality disciplines (vacuous-pass / NULL-strict / source-text-authority) not binding rules | added 4 guard-quality rules; G-NOLEGACY non-vacuity clause | all guards | no - reaffirms FIX5/FIX6 lessons + law §5 |
Blueprint docs touched (final revisions after the Max pass)
- 00 readme-first (rev 2)
- 01 live-existing-system-inventory (rev 3)
- 02 design-to-live-mapping (rev 5)
- 04 dependency-safe-construction-order (rev 13)
- 05 rollback-blueprint (rev 7)
- 06 test-guard-blueprint (rev 10)
- 07 implementation-package-split (rev 14)
- 08 hard-blocks-do-not-touch-list (rev 5)
- 12 final-verdict (rev 6)
- blueprint checkpoint (rev 5)
- BIRTH_GATEWAY_DESIGN_INDEX.md (rev 30 - Max banner appended)
(Docs 03 gap-classification, 09 embedded-XHigh, 10 embedded-Max, 11 embedded-revisions needed no change.)
Invariant non-regression after all Max revisions
| invariant | before | after |
|---|---|---|
| authority surfaces | 27 | 27 |
| runtime-evidence tables | 11 non-authority | 11 non-authority |
| readiness gates | 14 (DATA) | 14 (DATA) |
| top-level hash contracts | 7 (H01..H07) | 7 (H01..H07) |
| guards | 30 | 30 (tightened; none added/removed) |
| new gates / new hash contracts | 0 / 0 | 0 / 0 |
| production mutation | 0 | 0 |
| Stage 2.6B / permit / REAL_RUN / QT001 apply | blocked | blocked |
| hard blocks / do-not-touch | intact | intact |
No Max revision added an authority surface, gate, or hash, or relaxed any hard block. The revisions tightened bypass-set completeness, guard authority (PG-native), rollback concreteness, governance- change gating, status honesty, and inventory completeness.