KB-456A
Supertrack M — Feasibility / Scale Final Scan
3 min read Revision 1
fix7architecturet1-reviewfeasibilityscalesupertrack-m
13 — Supertrack M: feasibility / scale final scan
Verdict: FEASIBILITY_SCALE_VERIFIED.
| Check | Result | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| PG16.13 + pgcrypto feasibility | ✅ | digest(...,'sha256'), JSONB explicit-key build, typed domains, declarative range partitioning — all PG16 native |
| object-count-independent readiness | ✅ | CP-08: growth follows plans/runs, not business-object count; readiness is exact-set over sealed manifests |
| no hot-path full scan | ✅ | 7 high-volume tables range-partitioned on immutable event time; active lookup indexes defined (CP-08 doc 09) |
| no row-by-row apply path introduced by RP corrections | ✅ | corrections add fact tables + bindings + a deferred FK + manifest fields; no per-row apply loop |
| no unbounded hash over runtime object data | ✅ | H02/H05 aggregates are scoped per-activation/per-run and bounded by retention/partition; H01 excludes lifecycle/evidence |
| no unbounded dependency recursion | ✅ | H06 inputs already byte-defined; dependency total order is finite and bounded |
| no production-blocking locks | ✅ | DDL is candidate-phase, operator-gated; seal/activate gated on checks; no live lock introduced |
| retention / partitioning coherent | ✅ | storage-class-driven interval/capacity; archive copy→readback→hash-verify→detach; operator-gated maintenance |
| rollback returns safe-blocked state | ✅ | append-only; reversal = exact reverse order dropping only empty candidate-only objects; active/history never dropped |
| implementation can proceed without guessing after final approval | ⚠️ | blocked by P-01/P-02/P-03 — H04/H05/H02 are not yet byte-implementable without guessing (evidence-hash dereference, scope_hash composition, runtime-aggregate total orders) |
Calibration
The only failing bullet is "without guessing," and its failure mode is spec completeness, not
scale or PG16 feasibility. There is no SCALE_RISK_FAIL: no hot-path scan, no unbounded hash, no
row-by-row apply, no blocking lock. I therefore return FEASIBILITY_SCALE_VERIFIED and route the
no-guess deficiency to the proposal package (P-01..P-03), which is what drives the overall verdict.
Conclusion
Feasible on PG16.13 + pgcrypto, scale-safe, rollback-safe. Byte-implementable-without-guessing is gated on the three CP-06 hash-binding proposals.