KB-5B74

Supertrack I — Final Proposal Package (none blocking)

2 min read Revision 1
fix7architecturet1-reviewcp06proposal-packagesupertrack-i

09 — Supertrack I: Final Proposal Package

NO_REMAINING_PROPOSALS (0 blocking; 0 advisory requiring action).

All four prior proposals are resolved and verified against the real runtime-evidence DDL:

  • P-01 → P01_VERIFIED (evidence deref to evidence_registry.artifact_sha256 over the real NOT NULL *_evidence_id FKs).
  • P-02 → P02_VERIFIED (8-key H04_SCOPE_V1, all real NOT NULL signoff_binding columns).
  • P-03 → P03_VERIFIED (4 aggregate membership predicates + PK-terminated total orders, DDL-grounded).
  • P-04 → P04_VERIFIED (fail-closed extra-index disposition; sealed #20 promotion path).

The single FIX7 acceptance gate — "H04/H05/H02 byte-implementable; every sub-payload key resolves to a named table.column" — is MET.

One optional, non-blocking editorial observation (Codex may ignore)

  • id: OBS-01
  • severity: editorial (NON-blocking)
  • affected doc: CP-06 patch 01-p01-h04-evidence-hash-dereference.md
  • affected layer: H04 evidence-deref rationale prose
  • issue: the aside "equal artifact bytes with equal SHA-256 remain content-equivalent across registry UUIDs" describes a case that a UNIQUE evidence_registry.artifact_sha256 (CP-08 doc 09) makes unreachable (one content hash ⇒ one row ⇒ one UUID).
  • proposed correction (optional): drop "across registry UUIDs" or note the uniqueness.
  • why minor: the deref rule and its byte-implementability/determinism are unaffected; the substantive claim (H04 binds content, not the UUID identity) is correct.
  • how Codex verifies: confirm evidence_registry.artifact_sha256 UNIQUE; adjust the sentence if desired.
  • blocks final approval: NO.

No blocking item remains.

Back to Knowledge Hub knowledge/dev/reports/architecture/t1-fix7-final-short-review-after-cp06-patch-2026-06-08/09-proposal-package-if-any.md