KB-A949
Cross-Layer Boundary Self-Review
3 min read Revision 1
fix7codex-recheck-patchcross-layerboundariesself-review2026-06-08
11 - Cross-Layer Boundary Self-Review
Re-running Codex recheck CHECK_J (cross-layer boundary). Codex accepted the boundaries with a document-consistency fix only (the stale "operator permit", now resolved - doc 09).
Boundaries remain blocked / out of scope (unchanged by this patch)
| concern | status | note |
|---|---|---|
| Stage 2.6B (permit/run/keyset/resume + authority revoke) | BLOCKED_UNTIL_AUTHORITY | separate program; not authorized by FIX7 |
qt001_backfill_permit / admission permit |
BLOCKED | never opened in a blueprint/planning phase; never granted by operator_authorization |
| REAL_RUN | BLOCKED_UNTIL_AUTHORITY | real scale/capability execution; separate gate |
QT001 apply (fn_dot_birth_qt001_apply/sp_dot_birth_qt001_apply) |
BLOCKED since NOT_SAFE |
under FIX7 both are sealed STUB_FAIL_CLOSED members; never unlocked by operator_authorization |
| registry-pivot repoint (system-of-record cutover) | BLOCKED_UNTIL_AUTHORITY | gated on birth/governance/registry-truth; FIX7 repoint is the QT001 control-plane writer only |
| governance reconciliation / Đ43 / QT-006 / raw-birth managed-object truth | BLOCKED/OUT-OF-SCOPE | adjacent cross-layer tasks, not this refactor |
| manifest activation / repoint / owner-ACL cutover | OPERATOR_GATED | PKG-E stages, PKG-F activates+repoints+neutralizes, PKG-G remaining cutover - all operator-gated, fresh Codex re-audit before PKG-F/PKG-G |
Did the owner-semantics patch change any boundary?
No. The patch reorders S14-S16 and binds artifacts to approved surfaces; it opens no new live authority. Specifically:
operator_authorizationstill grants package execution only (evidence_registry-bound, G-NO-QT001-PERMIT-DURING-FIX7) - it opens no apply/admission/REAL_RUN/2.6B and creates no readiness gate.- Activation moving from PKG-E into PKG-F is still OPERATOR_GATED and still requires a fresh Codex
re-audit (it is a
governance_change, law §4Gstop_without_asking_if). - The owner transfer (S15.1) and ACL cutover (S16) are still control-object-scoped; Directus retains
authority over its
directus_*app tables and legitimately-owned business tables. - The birth gateway (
fn_birth_registry_auto+ family) and DOT-118/119 remain DO_NOT_TOUCH.
Self-check
CHECK_J (cross-layer): PASS. Stage 2.6B, QT001 apply, qt001_backfill_permit, REAL_RUN,
governance reconciliation, and registry-pivot all remain blocked/later; the document-consistency fix
(operator permit → operator_authorization) is applied.