T1 FIX7 Recheck-7 Constitution-14 SSOT Patch - Final Verdict
11 - Final Verdict
Final status
FIX7_REFACTOR_BLUEPRINT_T1_PATCHED_AFTER_CODEX_RECHECK_7_READY_FOR_CODEX_RECHECK_8
Summary
Codex recheck 7 accepted the deterministic extractor + the N1–N9 content-hash DAG + invariants + no runtime regression, but held authoring-planning approval on five Constitution-Article-14 / NT14 defects. T1 patched all five in-blueprint; nothing accepted reopened; no runtime design amendment.
- A revision-layer self-reference → own-revision removed from load-bearing authority (Option 1);
revision = NON_AUTHORITY_DIAGNOSTIC; finite ordered seal; weaker guarantee accepted + separation-of-duties.
+
G-NO-SELF-REVISION-ANCHOR. - B no single executable canonicalizer SSOT → authored
FIX7-CANON-V1-CANONICALIZER(executable + test vectors + invocation + I/O + failure statuses + AUTHORING_REQUIREMENT), pinned bycanonicalizer_sha256. +G-CANONICALIZER-SSOT-ONLY. - C duplicate canonical authority → one load-bearing contract; doc 00 sections + all reports demoted to
NON_AUTHORITY_EXPLANATION. +
G-NO-DUPLICATE-CANONICAL-AUTHORITY(= CodexG-CANONICAL-CONTRACT-SSOT-NO-DUPLICATE). - D document_id path alias → exact MCP id byte-for-byte; all aliases rejected. +
G-DOCUMENT-ID-CANONICAL-MCP. - E marker contract → closed kind enum + per-kind literal grammar consistency. +
G-MARKER-KIND-LITERAL-CONSISTENCY.
Guards 58 → 63; guard-quality rule 12. Invariants 27/11/14/7 preserved (SSOT is a pinned
construction-document TOOL, not a member — membership stays f2bda8…fe251 — and not a runtime
surface/gate/#20-col/catalog-family/8th-hash). Seal event → recheck 8.
Self-check — 22/22 computed (doc 07), exit 0
| # | check | verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | membership reproduces f2bda8…fe251 under the SSOT |
PASS (computed) |
| 2 | content-hash DAG acyclic; no self-revision input | PASS (computed) |
| 3 | checkpoint own-revision NOT load-bearing; self-edge → cycle detected | PASS (computed) |
| 4 | single canonicalizer SSOT pinned; --selftest exit 0 |
PASS (computed) |
| 5 | duplicate canonical authority fails closed | PASS |
| 6 | document_id: 10 alias classes rejected with named status | PASS (computed) |
| 7 | marker kind/literal: unknown/inconsistent/typo rejected | PASS (computed) |
| 8 | field TAB/null/empty rejected | PASS (computed) |
| 9 | no runtime surface/gate/#20/catalog/8th-hash added; membership unchanged | PASS (doc 08/09) |
| 10 | accepted items not reopened; hard blocks intact | PASS (doc 09) |
Why READY_FOR_CODEX_RECHECK_8 (not the other allowed statuses)
- Not
…_NEEDS_MORE_T1_WORK: all five blockers patched in-blueprint; SSOT authored + pinned; 5 guards + rule 12 in place; the Article-14 self-check passes computed, exit 0. - Not
…_FAIL_HARDCODE_OR_PG_NATIVE_GAP: the patch removes the disguised-fixed-behaviour path (one executable SSOT, no duplicate authority); adds no runtime authority/surface; accepted invariants preserved. - Not
READ_PATH_BLOCKED: the recheck-7 package, the recheck-6 patch, the current blueprint, and the law were all readable read-only.
What Codex must do at recheck 8
Run the SSOT canonicalizer over the approved content; confirm membership f2bda8…fe251; seal
canonicalizer_revision + canonicalizer_sha256 + every aggregate; flip envelope_state to SEALED;
author the CODEX_DETACHED_SEAL in the recheck-8 checkpoint without recording that checkpoint's own
revision (Option 1). Asks 8 + 18–24 enumerate this.
Boundaries
Do not claim implementation approval. Implementation, Stage 2.6B, qt001_backfill_permit, REAL_RUN, QT001
apply, manifest activation, repoint, owner/ACL cutover all remain BLOCKED. Production READ-ONLY throughout.
Next is Codex recheck 8 only.