KB-7021

12 — Final Summary

3 min read Revision 1

12 — Final Summary

Verdict: PARTIAL — RP_CONTRACT_CANONICALIZED_REGISTRY_BOUNDED_FULLPOP_GUARDED_WITH_2_REAL_COUNT_FAILS

All 10 phases executed. Every safe branch complete. Two architecture items remain (the 2 real count fails + true auto-scale registryization), plus the standing authority/operator blockers.

Phase outcomes

phase deliverable status
1 dual-path trusted baseline, no-fake locked DONE
2 divergence inventory + detector; v1 DEPRECATE / reliability CURRENT; 10 v1↔v2 drill divergences DONE
3 aliases 5 _current views live DONE
4 axis binding v_rp_axis_source_binding (2/5 registry-backed, live-derived) DONE (view; table = next)
5 registry-driven contract 87-parity; requires_view_edit=58 (bounded hardcode) DONE w/ explicit limitation
6 full-pop invariant 87/87 guarded; 81 PASS + 4 EXPECTED_BLOCKER + 2 FAIL DONE
7 computed proof verdict from invariant; ALL_AXES FAIL; can-fail proven DONE
8 static literal 1 STALE fixed in live ledger; detector + live ledger DONE (prod ledger untouched)
9 no-hardcode dashboard synthetic status + audit + scorecard (40/80/97.7) DONE
10 UI packet _current binding + badge spec DONE (docs only)

The 2 genuine architecture FAILs (next macro input)

  1. PROC:residual_reconcile — headline 8 (stale) vs grouped substrate 23 vs live 2. Fix: scope residual grouping to AWAITING_OWNER + align headline to live ledger.
  2. PROC:new_candidates — headline 6 candidates vs 50 members. Fix: declare count semantic (container vs contents) or split the node.

Blockers

  • Architecture (safe-eng, no authority): fix the 2 count/substrate reconciliations; build the v1-UNION → binding-driven generator for true auto-scale (58 nodes still need view-edit).
  • Authority (unchanged): president PROC-OWN vote (official RP 0/453), AX-PROCESS/AX-TOPIC owner, AX-TRIGGER axis registration owner.
  • Operator (unchanged): UI deploy of _current surfaces; real_run_enabled flip.

Next macro decision

RP_COUNT_SUBSTRATE_RECONCILIATION_FIX_AND_REGISTRYIZATION_GENERATOR (safe-engineering, no authority needed) — close the 2 invariant FAILs and replace v1's static UNION with a binding-driven generator so a new axis is one binding row. Then UI_CURRENT_PRODUCTIONIZATION (operator) and the standing authority macros.

Back to Knowledge Hub knowledge/dev/reports/architecture/rp-contract-canonical-registry-driven-fullpop-nohardcode-closeout-2026-06-05/12-final-summary.md