14 — Self-Review (Combined Macro 2+3)
title: 14 — Self-Review (Combined Macro 2+3) date: 2026-05-31 final_status: PASS (deferred path)
14 — Self-Review (Combined Macro 2+3)
Acceptance criteria (§15) — all met
| criterion | status |
|---|---|
| threshold/label grouping pack complete | ✅ doc 03 (display_policy rehearsed, 28/160, PIV-311=23) |
| registry pin pack complete | ✅ doc 04 (registry_pin rehearsed, REGISTRY_MISSING, scope CHECK) |
| phantom policy/law patch pack complete | ✅ doc 05 (source_model-aware, RG4 wording, event/issue mapping) |
| Directus/API exposure pack complete | ✅ doc 06 (8 endpoints, GOOD pattern, no-count rule, mock) |
| static UI preview v2 deployed or blocker | ✅ DEPLOYED, HTTP 200 (doc 07) |
| Nuxt render-shell pack complete | ✅ doc 08 (route/components/contract/states/a11y) |
| legacy retirement plan complete | ✅ doc 09 (file:line, parity gate, redirect, rollback, note) |
| production acceptance suite complete | ✅ doc 10 (13 tests; 8 ran read-only PASS) |
| no-hardcode evidence exists | ✅ doc 12 |
| next macro prompts exist | ✅ doc 13 (F1/F2/F3/L1) |
| no unsafe mutation occurred | ✅ verified (clean-slate proof + idle 0) |
Result: PASS (not PARTIAL — every required pack is complete; the only deferrals are approval-gated commits, which is the correct state).
Forbidden compliance (§14) — clean
No COMMIT · no self-approval · no persistent PG mutation (BEGIN..ROLLBACK only, PRE==POST, idle 0) · no Directus mutation · no Qdrant write · no production Nuxt change · no route cutover · no legacy retirement · no fake approvals · no frontend business logic introduced · no hardcoded counts/categories/species/layers/labels/pins/thresholds in produced artifacts · no event/job executed · no notification emitted · static preview versioned (v2 beside v1, not overwritten) · no idle transaction left.
Evidence quality
- Every headline number is a live read or a BEGIN..ROLLBACK rehearsal this run, not recalled. Approval verdict re-derived from 4 PG surfaces + keyword scan.
- The net_gap moved within the session (CAT-023 +1) and that is reported as the live-race proof, not smoothed over.
- Six-object SQL pack (001..006) verified still on disk and matches the committed-design DDL; re-rehearsal of the new objects (display_policy/registry_pin/parent_code) ran GREEN.
What I deliberately did NOT do
- Did not re-INSERT the pivot bundle this run (each pivot_definitions INSERT fires a statement-level full refresh; Macro 1 already engine-proved it). Avoided unnecessary load.
- Did not register Directus collections (needs views committed + Directus write approval).
- Did not touch
/knowledge/registriesor any Nuxt file.
Honest gaps / risks carried forward
- PIV-500/301/302/303 are view-backed → cannot exist until v_count_rollup_src + v_count_drift are committed (F1 ordering enforced in doc 11).
- Phantom is a genuine LAW_DEFINITION_GAP — needs council, not engineering (RG4/L1).
- CAT-023 net_gap grows until scan cadence is fixed; CAT-1006..1010 still unmeasured.
- Acceptance tests 7–9 (API/UI/legacy) are spec-only until their gates open — flagged, not hidden.
Confidence
High. The deferred-path deliverable is complete and safe; the foundation is hot; the next 4 macros are scoped and gate-ordered. The only thing standing between here and production is human/council approval, exactly as the constitution requires.