KB-639F
RP DOT Cleanup — 09 Final Go/No-Go (PARTIAL, zero mutation)
3 min read Revision 1
registries-pivotgo-nogopartialzero-mutation-proof2026-06-03
09 — Final Go / No-Go
Status: PARTIAL — PASS on all analysis/design objectives; DOT execution correctly HELD.
Per Completion criteria: criteria 1–4, 6–11 met; criterion 5 satisfied as "correctly held" (PARTIAL clause) — DOT execution blocked with an exact reason (no update-capable pivot DOT exists), with the unblock packaged.
Objective verdicts
| Obj | Verdict | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| State recovery | ✅ PASS | doc 01; KB + local sources reconciled |
| Live preflight (Gate 0) | ✅ PASS | DB=directus, view 37, L2 closed, triggers characterized |
| A — DOT binding | ✅ PASS | doc 02; bound to actual scripts; A/B proven unbindable |
| B — DOT rehearsal | ✅ PASS | doc 03; read-only preview; retire+recreate non-viable |
| C — Execute safe cleanup | ⏸️ HELD (correct) | doc 04; zero bindable safe op → 0 mutations |
| D — Naming packet | ✅ PASS | doc 05; grouped, recommended, not self-ratified |
| E — Anti-drift health | ✅ PASS | doc 06 + sql/01,02; 9 checks validated live |
| F — UI/API handoff | ✅ PASS | doc 07; contract, badges, banner, JSON, forbiddens |
| G — Next build plan | ✅ PASS | doc 08; author dot-pivot-update → cleanup → schema split |
| KB published / readable | ✅ (this publish step) | doc 10 verifies |
Zero-mutation proof (entry == exit)
| metric | entry | exit | Δ |
|---|---|---|---|
pivot_definitions md5 |
4eb00c8fe4d0937325278d7e5e12b7a3 | 4eb00c8fe4d0937325278d7e5e12b7a3 | 0 |
| base rows | 37 | 37 | 0 |
| ospa / ownership / gap / gov_emit | 0/0/210/0 | 0/0/210/0 | 0 |
| RP views | v_rp_classification_governance_map | (same; health view NOT applied) | 0 |
Remaining blockers (precise)
- Tooling gap (non-L2): no update-capable governed pivot DOT. Unblock = author + register
dot-pivot-update(sql/05_*) — owner-operated engineering. - Council naming (non-L2): Action-B FAC-02 targets incl. workflow-family LBL-104-vs-new-LBL-106 decision (doc 05).
- L2 rollout (unchanged, independent): human L2/L4 ospa≥1 — gates only the separate governance-rollout macro, not RP classification.
Go / No-Go calls
- GO now (no gate): RP UI/API consumption of the live view; anti-drift suite on cron.
- GO on owner-go (no L2): author dot-pivot-update → run Action A (mismatch 3→0).
- GO on council ratify (no L2): Action B domain assignments.
- NO-GO (this macro, correctly): any pivot mutation (no safe tool); applying the health view (out of scope); L2 rollout (gate closed).
Next macro
REGISTRIES_PIVOT_DOT_PIVOT_UPDATE_AUTHOR_AND_CLEANUP (owner-go): author+register dot-pivot-update, run Action A, ratify+run Action B, design the schema split. Independent: ONE_ROOF_PRODUCTION_ROLLOUT_EXECUTE_ON_RATIFICATION (L2, ospa≥1).