KB-5473
PD Runtime Observation — 06 KG/dot-kg Rescoring
3 min read Revision 1
06 — KG / dot-kg Rescoring After Observation (Workstream E)
Before → after (the only candidate that moved is dot:kg)
| candidate | v2 readiness_class | v3 candidate_status | v3 gate | moved? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| job:cut | verified_candidate (conf 100) | verified_candidate | VERIFIED_PENDING_OWNER | no (already real) |
| dot:kg | runtime_missing (conf 50) | simulated_observed | SIMULATED_PROOF_ONLY_NOT_VERIFIED | yes |
| dot:doc / dot:kb / dot:nrm | runtime_missing (50) | structural_candidate | BLOCKED_NEEDS_RUNTIME_AND_CORRELATION | no |
| dot:gov | structural_weak (30) | structural_candidate | BLOCKED_NEEDS_EVIDENCE | no |
| dot:schema (34) / collection / migration / birth | not_a_process | structural_candidate | BLOCKED_NEEDS_EVIDENCE | no |
| dot:api/field/script/seed/sync, wf:WF-001/002 (1 member) | not_a_process | not_a_process | NOT_A_PROCESS | no |
dot:kg flag delta (honest)
| flag | before | after | note |
|---|---|---|---|
| runtime_missing | true | true | no REAL_RUN; simulated does not satisfy runtime |
| correlation_missing | true | simulated correlation present (1 corr_id over 2 components) | proves wiring, not the process |
| event_missing | true | true | process.* still inactive |
| owner_missing | true | true | no owner registered |
| confidence (verified scale) | 50 | 50 | unchanged — simulated must not inflate |
| evidence tier | none | SIMULATED_DRY_RUN | new |
The 18 KG pairs / 10 law processes A–J
- All 18 KG producer/verifier pairs remain structural_candidate at the family level; only the
DOT_KG_EXPLAINpair carries a simulated observation, and that rolls up to the singledot:kgcandidate assimulated_observed. The other 17 pairs have no observation. - The 10 KG law processes (A–J) are not individually born candidates in this discovery model —
dot:kgis one rolled-up candidate (36 members). They remain atsimulated_observedcollectively via the one pilot run; none is verified. No per-law promotion performed. - Overall dot-kg family verdict:
simulated_observed— NOT verified, NOT birth-ready. The simulated run is a substrate/correlation proof, explicitly not process proof.
Honest summary
The macro raised dot:kg exactly one rung — from "structurally a candidate with no runtime evidence" to "the ledger + correlation path is proven via a clearly-labelled simulation." It did not make dot:kg verified, did not raise its confidence, and did not move it toward birth. That requires a REAL_RUN (or approved DRY_RUN) through an execution wrapper.