KB-5592
12 — Self-Review — PASS (Phase-1 Test-Mode Build, 2026-06-02)
3 min read Revision 1
one-roof-governancephase1test-mode-buildself-review2026-06-02
12 — Self-Review
| # | Criterion | Verdict | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Test-mode authority documented | ✅ | doc 00 §0.3 (owner's explicit delegation; reversible+internal clears confirm-first bar) |
| 2 | Live preflight complete (Hard Gate 0) | ✅ | doc 01 (channel, backup, object state, counts, trigger analysis, worker check) |
| 3 | ≥ SB-0 built + verified | ✅ | doc 03 — and in fact 7/7 areas built |
| 4 | Every committed step within authorized scope | ✅ | only SB-0/1/12/13/10/11/2 objects + legitimate seeds |
| 5 | Every committed step verified post-COMMIT | ✅ | docs 03-08 + doc 09 (independent channel) |
| 6 | No out-of-scope mutation | ✅ | doc 09 §9.3 — appr/votes/osprop/outbox/relations Δ=0; only intended birth(+8)+guard-audit(+1) |
| 7 | No production activation | ✅ | all tables empty/inactive; verifier=0; SB-11 active=false |
| 8 | Rollback readiness documented | ✅ | doc 10 (6 scripts + backup + drop order) |
| 9 | Final state clear | ✅ | doc 11 |
| 10 | F-83-1 fix applied + verified before vocab insert | ✅ | doc 08 (Phase-A proof; atomic CREATE OR REPLACE TRIGGER; birth_null=0) |
| 11 | handler_ref fail-closed / no approval rows by SB-1 | ✅ | 8 rows unimplemented; appr=211 unchanged |
| 12 | No hardcode / no island | ✅ | vocab=rows; FKs→live registries; quorum recompute mirrors live fn_apr_quorum_check |
| 13 | No claim ratification is solved | ✅ | doc 00 §0.2, doc 11 §11.2 |
12.1 Honest limitations
- SB-10 auxiliaries (
candidate_scan_run,governance_candidate_object) and SB-2 recursive inheritance views (v_object_owner_gap+ inheritance walk) were deferred, not built — exact literal DDL was not retrievable at commit-fidelity, and improvising onto a live DB was declined per the no-improvise discipline. Documented in docs 02/05/07/11. The keystonegovernance_candidate_stateand direct-ownershipv_object_effective_ownerARE committed and correct. - The SB-1 trigger fix is the one production-shared change; it is a strict repair (atomic, reversible, shared function untouched) and is the only change with a side-effect beyond the new substrate (+8 birth rows, +1 guard-audit row), both intended/benign and documented.
- This build is test-mode scaffolding on the production DB; it does not and cannot substitute for the human L2+L4 ratification.
12.2 Overall
PASS. Maximum useful test substrate reached safely: 7/7 authorized areas committed, every step rehearsed-then-verified, zero out-of-scope/forbidden mutation, full rollback readiness, and the long-term governance gate explicitly preserved (not claimed solved).