08 — Final GO/NO-GO (GO read-only/rollback-only dry-run F-1/F-2; NO-GO activation F-4+; ratification gate preserved; 2026-06-02)
08 — Final GO / NO-GO (for a future dry-run macro)
8.1 Verdict
GO — for a read-only / rollback-only dry-run (F-1, optionally F-2) ONLY. NO-GO — for any activation, emit, persistent seam COMMIT, seeded persistent run, worker start, or DOT (F-4+).
The substrate is ready to be exercised read-only; it is not cleared to be activated. The two are separated by the unsolved L2+L4 ratification gate.
8.2 GO conditions (all currently TRUE — re-verify immediately before the macro)
| # | Condition | Live (2026-06-02) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | All Phase-1 substrate present + inert | ✅ 8 tables + 6 views, all 0 except scope 6 |
| 2 | Gate intact | ✅ os_proposal_approvals=0 |
| 3 | Events inactive, 0 emit | ✅ 5 gov types active=0, emit=0 |
| 4 | No worker / no DOT | ✅ cursor=0, dot_tools=309 |
| 5 | Clean tx state | ✅ idle_in_transaction=0 |
| 6 | Seam sources enumerable & bounded | ✅ collection_registry 168 (35 governed) |
| 7 | Dry-run scope minimal & defined | ✅ 3 collections, ≤3 gap rows (doc 03) |
| 8 | Zero-emit boundary defined | ✅ log-only (doc 06) |
| 9 | Strict gates defined | ✅ 10 pre-flight + in-flight + post (doc 05) |
| 10 | Rollback staged | ✅ SB-2 inert-restore script on disk |
8.3 NO-GO conditions (any TRUE blocks the corresponding step)
- L2+L4 ratification absent (
os_proposal_approvals=0) ⇒ NO-GO for F-4 seam COMMIT and all activation. (currently TRUE — activation blocked.) - Axis substrate (
axis_registry/axis_assignment/coverage_rule) unbuilt ⇒ NO-GO for any axis/assignment coverage dry-run. (currently TRUE — axis coverage blocked.) - Object-grain dry-run requested ⇒ NO-GO (1.08M source; collection-grain only for first run).
- Any emit /
system_issues/ notification requested ⇒ NO-GO (zero-emit boundary).
8.4 Scope of the GO
The GO authorizes a future macro to run:
- F-1 read-only: evaluate the Seam-A SELECT expression + gap logic over 3 governed collections via
query_pg. Zero DDL, zero transaction. - F-2 rollback-only (if F-1 clean): wire seams + draft ruleset inside
BEGIN..ROLLBACK, verify the path, ROLLBACK, prove entry==exit.
Nothing beyond F-2 is in scope of this GO.
8.5 Remaining blockers (to activation, not to the dry-run)
- L2 council + L4 sovereign ratification of the authorization model (the one gate) — human-only; agent cannot satisfy.
- Axis substrate build (ratified follow-up) — unblocks axis/assignment coverage.
- Ratified seam-wiring decision (collection-grain inventory; acyclic containment) — coverage/coupling decision, not engineering.
8.6 Next macro
ONE_ROOF_PHASE1_COVERAGE_DRY_RUN_F1_READONLY — execute the read-only dry-run (F-1) per docs 03/05/06, log-only, then optionally F-2 rollback-only. In parallel: GPT review of this readiness package; human B-RATIFY intake for the authorization model.
8.7 Final GO/NO-GO verdict
GO (read-only/rollback-only dry-run) · NO-GO (activation). Bounded, gated, reversible, zero-emit. The activation boundary is explicit and the ratification gate is preserved.