KB-4B94

Gate-Resolution 00 — Overview, State Recovery & Decision (Path C / NO COMMIT)

4 min read Revision 1
one-roofphase1coveragegate-resolutionownership-seedpath-cno-commitratification-gateospa2026-06-02

00 — Overview, State Recovery & Decision

Mission: ONE_ROOF_PHASE1_COVERAGE_HUMAN_GATE_OR_TESTMODE_COMMIT_DECISION_AND_EXECUTION Date: 2026-06-02 Class: Gate resolution + conditional persistent commit (30-anchor ownership seed). Outcome: PARTIAL — Path C (NO COMMIT). Authorization gate is live-verified CLOSED. No forbidden action occurred. Forward-velocity deliverables (human-action packet + one-shot commit-ready SQL + verification) produced.


Executive verdict

Item Verdict
State recovery COMPLETE
Live preflight (Hard Gate 0) PASS — substrate matches proven baseline exactly; no drift except organic background tables
Authorization path PATH C — no authorization to commit
Persistent commit NOT DONE (correctly withheld)
Scanner read verification Re-confirmed read-only against live state; persisted-state verification deferred to post-ratification
Rollback path STAGED (sql/rollback_f6_ownership_seed.sql)
Human-action packet PRODUCED (doc 04)
Activation matrix COMPLETE (doc 08)
Forbidden compliance CLEAN — zero persistent mutation this run
Final NO-GO for persistent commit; GO for human ratification (5-box, minutes)

What has been technically proven (carried forward, re-verified live this run)

  • F-4 seams committed and live: v_governance_object_inventory = 35, v_governance_object_containment = 35, depth-1 acyclic group containment.
  • Active scopes = 6 (governance_responsibility_scope.status='active').
  • Baseline gap = 210 (= 35 governed objects × 6 scopes), honest under-coverage with ownership empty.
  • Full coverage 210 → 0 provable with exactly 30 group-level accountable anchors (5 groups × 6 scopes), depth-1 containment fan-out (F-5 rollback-only seam proof; F-6 full-scale rollback-only).
  • Direct-override precedence (depth-0 beats inherited depth-1), scaled UNIQUE-conflict prevention, and 6 fail-closed negatives all proven in-transaction.
  • Scanner read path is a pure SELECT (safe); coverage is computable read-only.
  • governance_object_ownership has 0 triggers → inserts/deletes are inert (no emit/issue/cascade). Reversible by delete-by-key.

What authorization states exist

  • L2 quorum approval of the auth model: absent.
  • L4 President e-signature of the auth model: absent.
  • os_proposal_approvals (machine-checkable proxy for L2+L4): 0 (live).
  • The auth-model approval request (APR-BOOT-AUTHMODEL-1): does not exist on the spine — the human process has not begun.

What this macro may commit

  • Nothing persistent. The only conditionally-authorized write (the 30-anchor seed) is blocked because its authorization predicate is unmet (see doc 02).

What remains forbidden

Everything in mission §10, plus — this run — the 30-anchor seed itself, because the gate is closed.

Stop / downgrade rules applied

  • Mission §4 Path B requires a non-production inert seed. Verified fact: current_database()='directus' is production; there is no separate test DB. The "non-production" predicate is objectively false → Path B unavailable.
  • Mission §4 Path B: "if any doubt, do not commit." There is not merely doubt — there is a verified blocking fact.
  • Mission §7: when commit is not allowed, do not redo technical rehearsals; produce the human-action packet + exact next command. Followed: no rollback rehearsal was run; only a read-only drift-preflight (legitimately needed) and read-only scanner re-confirmation.

See doc 01 (preflight evidence), doc 02 (authorization decision), doc 04 (human-action packet), doc 08 (activation matrix), doc 09 (GO/NO-GO + next macro).

Back to Knowledge Hub knowledge/dev/reports/architecture/one-roof-phase1-coverage-gate-resolution-and-ownership-seed-decision-2026-06-02/00-overview-state-recovery-and-decision.md