08 — Self-Review

Adversarial pass. Verdict: PASS (12/12).

1. Exactly two views committed, nothing else? Only 2 CREATE OR REPLACE VIEW + 2 COMMENT; all 16 out-of-scope counters Δ=0. PASS
2. Mandatory F2-1 cast included? collection_name::text AS object_ref (both) + "group"::text AS parent_ref (seam B). PASS
3. Post-commit ceilings verify? seamA=35, seamB=35, depth=1, gap=210. PASS
4. Commit self-guarding? DO-block assertion would abort txn on deviation; raised only NOTICE → committed safely. PASS
5. Preflight real and complete? 15-point Hard Gate 0 all PASS on both channels; same DB (registry=168). PASS
6. Acyclicity re-run over all 35? Yes pre-commit (35/35, depth=1) and post-commit on live view (35, depth=1, no cycle). PASS
7. Hidden write path? view_triggers=0, extra_rules=0 (only _RETURN). No INSTEAD OF. PASS
8. Rollback staged + lossless? sql/f4_seam_rollback.sql written pre-commit; views store no rows; matches canonical inert DDL. PASS
9. Activation kept NO-GO? scanner/worker/emit/issue/DOT/owners/candidates/rulesets untouched; gov events active=0. PASS
10. Ratification status honest? ospa stayed 0; basis=TEST_MODE_OPERATOR_AUTHORIZATION; L2/L4 explicitly deferred, not solved; doc 08 §8.5/§8.7 tension surfaced in doc 01, not buried. PASS
11. Directus/Qdrant/Nuxt/UI touch? None. PASS
12. FS-only trap — package actually in KB? Ingested + verified by list/get/search. PASS

Honest caveats

• This run persists state under operator (not sovereign) authorization. The seams now see governed objects — the inert→visible boundary for the coverage path. Reversible in one statement; nothing downstream consumes it yet; but it is a real standing change, not a rehearsal. Surfaced plainly.
• Durable L2+L4 ratification is not solved. Any emit/persist-issue/seed-owner/scan/activate step remains NO-GO.
• requires_owner uses governance_role IN ('governed','locked'); the WHERE already filters to governed, so the column is true for all 35 today (the locked arm is forward-looking, harmless).

Self-review verdict: PASS — minimal, verified, reversible, honestly bounded.