F-3 Consolidation Rollback-Only Coverage Dry-Run — 09 Final GO/NO-GO
09 — Final GO / NO-GO for Next Step
9.1 F-3 status: PASS (12/12 objectives)
| # | Objective | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Corrected seam DDL collection_name::text compiles |
✅ both seams (A1/B1/B2) |
| 2 | Bounded inventory over expanded subset | ✅ 35 (full) + 10 (subset) |
| 3 | Gap rows = object×scope ceiling minus covered | ✅ 210 full / 60→55 subset |
| 4 | Direct owner resolves | ✅ workflows/policy + GRP-GOVERNANCE node (depth 0) |
| 5 | Inherited owner resolves | ✅ 4 GRP-GOVERNANCE children (depth 1, real edge) |
| 6 | Missing owner remains gap | ✅ workflow_steps + 4 GRP-REGISTRY (6/6) |
| 7 | Conflict detection exercised | ✅ E6=0 (index) / E7=1 (predicate) |
| 8 | Containment / parent-child tested if safe | ✅ real collection_registry."group", acyclic depth-1 |
| 9 | Negative tests reject malformed rows | ✅ 7/7 (UNIQUE/2×FK/3×CHECK/candidate FK) |
| 10 | No event/issue/DOT/worker/handler activation | ✅ gov_emit 0, sys_issues 198,442, active=0 |
| 11 | ROLLBACK restores entry state | ✅ Δ=0 on 2 channels; seams inert; no probe leak |
| 12 | F-4 readiness packet concrete | ✅ doc 08 (DDL/ceilings/forbidden/stop/rollback/gate) |
No objective was skipped for safety. (The full-35 in-transaction inventory was safe — 210 bounded rows, sub-second — so it was executed rather than left to a read-only estimate.)
9.2 GO / NO-GO matrix
| Next step | Decision | Rationale |
|---|---|---|
| F-4 seam COMMIT (wire both views for real) | NO-GO until L2+L4 ratification | Engineering-ready (doc 08), but the COMMIT crosses inert→active for coverage and requires sovereign ratification; os_proposal_approvals=0. |
| GPT review of F-3 package | GO (parallel) | Independent verification of this package; recommended before F-4 authorization. |
| Human B-RATIFY (L2+L4) | GO (the only unblock) | Records the build-authorization that lets F-4 COMMIT. Human-only act. |
| Another rollback-only dry-run (e.g. all 35 with ownership) | OPTIONAL GO | Safe, but F-3 already proved the path at full ceiling + real containment; marginal value. |
| Object-grain / axis / activation (F-5..F-7) | NO-GO | birth_registry cursor (SB-13) not exercised; axis substrate ABSENT; ratification-gated. |
9.3 Recommended next macro
ONE_ROOF_PHASE1_COVERAGE_DRY_RUN_F4_SEAM_COMMIT — gated on L2+L4 ratification. It executes doc 08 verbatim: BEGIN → wire Seam A + Seam B (cast-corrected) → assert 210 ceiling + full-35 acyclicity → COMMIT only if os_proposal_approvals≥1/ratified governance_build_authorization valid, else ROLLBACK. Runs in parallel with: GPT review of this F-3 package; human B-RATIFY (the actual unblock).
9.4 Remaining blockers
- L2+L4 ratification (the one gate) —
os_proposal_approvals=0; no build-authorization row exists. Human-only. - Missing GPT-review artifacts (F-1→F-2, F-2→F-3) and empty governing law file — documentation/reconciliation items, not authorization gaps (doc 02 §2.3).
- Object-grain, axis layer, activation — out of scope for the seam-commit step; separate ratified work.
9.5 Final decision
GO_F4_READINESS_COMPLETE — F4_COMMIT_NO_GO_PENDING_RATIFICATION.
F-3 PASS. The F-4 plan is concrete and rehearsed; the seams remain inert. The next state transition (F-4 COMMIT) is unblocked only by human L2+L4 ratification. No further dry-run engineering is required to be F-4-ready.