KB-111B

05 — Entry==Exit & No-Mutation Verification (Δ=0 across all 24 surfaces; structural read-only + empirical census; system_issues & gov emit unchanged; 2026-06-02)

4 min read Revision 1
one-roof-governancephase1coverage-dry-runf1-readonlyentry-equals-exitno-mutationverification2026-06-02

05 — Entry==Exit & No-Mutation Verification

The full census battery was run via read-only query_pg before (doc 01) and after the dry-run SELECTs. This doc proves byte-for-byte equality.

5.1 Entry vs Exit table

Surface Entry (preflight) Exit (post-dry-run) Δ
governance_build_authorization 0 0 0
governance_ruleset 0 0 0
gov_worker_cursor 0 0 0
governance_candidate_state 0 0 0
governance_candidate_object 0 0 0
candidate_scan_run 0 0 0
governance_object_ownership 0 0 0
governance_responsibility_scope 6 6 0
v_governance_object_inventory (seam) 0 0 0
v_governance_object_containment (seam) 0 0 0
v_object_effective_owner 0 0 0
v_object_owner_gap 0 0 0
v_object_owner_conflict 0 0 0
v_build_auth_valid 0 0 0
os_proposal_approvals 0 0 0
approval_requests 211 211 0
apr_approvals 42 42 0
governance_relations 8 8 0
dot_tools 309 309 0
system_issues 198,442 198,442 0
event_outbox (governance) 0 0 0
event_type_registry (governance active) 0 0 0
birth_registry 1,079,562 1,079,562 0
idle_in_transaction 0 0 0

Every surface unchanged. Δ = 0 everywhere.

5.2 No-mutation argument (two independent guarantees)

  1. Structural: every statement ran through query_pg, which is AST-validated READ ONLY, executed by a read-only role inside a READ ONLY transaction (statement_timeout 5s, LIMIT 500). A write/DDL is rejected before execution. Mutation was impossible by construction.
  2. Empirical: the entry/exit census (5.1) shows zero delta across all governance and out-of-scope surfaces, including the two surfaces the dry-run could conceivably have touched (system_issues, governance event_outbox) — both unchanged.

5.3 Required checks (mission §5) — all PASS

Check Result
event_outbox governance emit unchanged ✅ 0 → 0
system_issues count unchanged ✅ 198,442 → 198,442
candidate tables unchanged candidate_state/candidate_object/candidate_scan_run all 0
owner tables unchanged governance_object_ownership 0; responsibility_scope 6
worker cursor unchanged gov_worker_cursor 0
approval / e-sign counts unchanged ✅ ospa 0; appr 211; apr_appr 42
dot_tools unchanged ✅ 309
idle_in_transaction=0 ✅ 0
no persistent object created ✅ no DDL issued; views/tables identical
no mutation occurred ✅ structural + empirical

5.4 Session hygiene

No workflow_admin / ssh write session was ever opened — the rollback-only channel was deliberately not used. The only DB session attributable to this mission is the read-only query_pg verifier (state=active transiently, then gone). No lingering session; idle in transaction=0 entry and exit.

5.5 Birth-registry note

birth_registry read 1,079,562 at both entry and exit of this mission — stable across the run window. (Prior-session close recorded 1,079,560; the +2 is organic non-governance growth between sessions, not attributable to this read-only run, which cannot write.)

5.6 Verification verdict

ENTRY == EXIT. ZERO MUTATION. PROVEN both structurally and empirically.

Back to Knowledge Hub knowledge/dev/reports/architecture/one-roof-phase1-coverage-dry-run-f1-readonly-2026-06-02/05-entry-exit-and-no-mutation-verification.md