01 — State Recovery & Round-3 Verification (Branch A) (2026-06-01)
01 — State Recovery & Round-3 Verification (Branch A)
Method: All prior packages re-read from KB (four parallel extraction passes) and cross-checked against ~22 live read-only PG queries this session. Old reports are treated as evidence, not authority — live verification wins (mission standard §"Old reports are evidence, not authority").
1.1 What each round completed
Round 1 — Decision Pack (one-roof-governance-decision-pack-2026-06-01/, 14 docs)
- Verdict: federated-but-central — the central governance roof already exists and is sufficient as a spine; the defect is incomplete coverage, not absence of governance. Owners: policy→GOV-COUNCIL, health/integrity→GOV-SIV, DOT-exec→GOV-DOT, render→GOV-MOUT (after activation). All bound to the one
governance_registry+ Đ32 approval spine + Đ31/45 issue-event substrate. No surface may mint a local owner/approval/policy. - Delivered: governed-object contract (effect-on-truth-or-authority test, 18 logical links resolved relationally not as columns), orphan/anarchic/island taxonomy (12 gap types OWNER_GAP…GOVERNANCE_SCHEMA_DRIFT), the coverage accounting identity (
total = covered + orphans + approved_exceptions + retired_or_ignored, must close per scope at object-grain), a 6-layer detector design, 7 GOV-DOTs, draft clauses (Đ37 §4.15-18, §5.4-EXT object-edges DEFERRED, Đ31/35/24-29/26/28/45). - Left open (doc 13 §13.5): §5.4-EXT decision, GOV-MOUT activation, human-only law ratification, phantom definition wording, Direct-PG exception ratification.
Round 2 — Clause Review & Hardening (one-roof-governance-clause-review-hardening-2026-06-01/, 17 docs)
- Verdict: NO-GO for canonical design until Tier-1 folded; GO after one revision; CONDITIONAL GO for the 2 concept docs (P-09.1 + P-09.4) if they carry hardened defs + flag T1-6.
- Found 6 internal contradictions (B5 exception-as-owner-path; F1 per-object vs container grain; F3 gate covered==true vs warning-non-blocking; I2 APPLY writes object-owner edge but live CHECK blocks it → object-grain remediation inoperable; C2 federated multi-owner vs Đ37 §4.12 one-owner; D2 anarchic "capacity" circular), 6 gaps (A2/B1 no Class 0; C1 no role taxonomy; D1 no birth↔gov dedup; E1 no replacement_plan; G2 no route registry; K1/K3 gate not tiered / no waiver), 3 live traps (object edges CHECK-blocked; no
grant_exception/assign_owneraction-type; dormant events mis-named — baregovernance.*undermother, notmother.governance.*). - Delivered hardened wording M-DEF-1..7 + revised Đ37/31/35/24-29/26/28/45; 19 open questions (OQ-A2…OQ-K6); 6 next prompts; reclassified §5.4-EXT deferred→Tier-1 prerequisite (T1-6).
Round 3 — Hardening Revision (All Domains / All Axes) (one-roof-governance-hardening-revision-all-domains-all-axes-2026-06-01/, 17 docs)
- Folded Tier-1: T1-1..T1-5 and T1-7 resolved as wording; T1-6 reclassified "deferred"→"PREREQUISITE" (the single residual, a substrate delta: object/axis ownership edge §5.4-EXT + 4 APR action-types).
- Added the system-wide Open Axis Model (M-DEF-8 axis = a governed object; M-DEF-9 Axis Registry = governed registry, nine attributes, no hardcoded axis array), IU as first-class governed domain (Đ44-DRAFT family under Đ38; 17 mapped classes + 1 future catch-all; recon/vector/relation non-exemptable invariants; OP-B owner=TBD), 13 object classes, the §0-GOV hook for future laws, coverage invariant v2 (governance grain, Δtotal=0 on +10⁶ children, owner-link-only inheritance), noise/scale control.
- Red-Team v2 = 48 scenarios (24 rerun + 24 new): 48/48 (100%) caught-or-classified, 44 (91.7%) auto-remediable, 4 🟧 pending T1-6 (#13,#14,#36,#45), 0 ❌.
- Verdict: CONDITIONAL GO — concept docs GO; apply/remediation NO-GO until T1-6; IU surface NO-GO until OP-B. 8 next prompts. Self-review: PASS, 18 forbidden actions complied, zero mutation.
1.2 Round-3 verification — VERIFIED (true continuation)
| Check (mission §5) | Result |
|---|---|
| 1. All 17 docs present? | YES — 00–16 listed live in KB this session. |
| 2. Docs content-substantial, not stubs? | YES — 8 core docs re-read in full; lengths 8–16 KB each; no stubs. |
| 3. Doc 14 states CONDITIONAL GO? | YES — §14.1 verbatim "CONDITIONAL GO"; 3-track table. |
| 4. Doc 13 contains consolidated hardened defs? | YES — M-DEF-1..9 + Đ37 §4.15-bis/ter/quater + §0-GOV hook, verbatim. |
| 5. Doc 03 contains IU coverage? | YES — 17-class table, island finding, non-exemptable invariants, OP-B. |
| 6. Doc 02 contains future/open-axis model? | YES — M-DEF-8/9, 9-attr registry, "no fixed axis array" (§2.10). |
| 7. Doc 12 contains 48 red-team scenarios? | YES — 24 rerun + 24 new, full table, catch status. |
| 8. Doc 16 confirms no mutation? | YES — 18 forbidden actions, 11 read-only queries, 17 KB uploads only. |
| 9. Distinguishes patch-now vs not? | YES — concept GO / apply NO-GO(T1-6) / IU-surface NO-GO(OP-B) / enact NO-GO. |
| 10. Any claims unsupported by evidence? | Mostly no — but 3 internal discrepancies (below); all cosmetic/wording, none load-bearing. |
Verdict: VERIFIED — Round 3 is a true continuation of Round 2 (it folds exactly the Round-2 Tier-1 blockers and the 19 OQ defaults; it does not restart). Live re-verification this session independently reproduced every load-bearing Round-3 substrate claim (governance_relations CHECK = {law,agency}; apr_action_types = 6 with 2 unimplemented; os_proposal_approvals=0; mother.* events active=false; dot_coverage_required lacks classification/pivot/IU/axis; no GOV-IU agency; normative_registry 47 with Đ44/45/20/23 absent).
1.3 Three internal Round-3 discrepancies — corrected here (Round-4 authoritative)
These are wording/counting drift inside Round-3 docs, not analytical errors. Round 4 fixes the authoritative value so the final package (doc 10) is internally consistent.
| # | Discrepancy | Authoritative Round-4 value |
|---|---|---|
| D-1 | Doc 00 §0.5 says red-team "46/48 (95.8%), 2 🟧"; doc 12 says "48/48 (100%) caught-or-classified, 44 (91.7%) auto-remediable, 4 🟧" | 48/48 = 100% caught-or-classified; 44 = 91.7% auto-remediable; 4 🟧 (#13,#14,#36,#45) pending T1-6; 0 ❌. (doc 12 is authoritative; doc 00 under-counted.) Round-4 Red-Team v3 supersedes (doc 09). |
| D-2 | AXIS coverage profile is "Class 4" in doc 02 §2.1 but "Class 3" in doc 13 M-DEF-8 |
Canonical = the profile name AXIS; the numeric class index is non-load-bearing and is frozen as Class 3 (per the consolidated clause doc 13). Final package references the profile by name, not number, to retire the ambiguity. |
| D-3 | Doc 03 says "17 mapped classes" but its §3.3 table has 17 named rows + an 18th "IU future axes" catch-all | 17 mapped IU classes + 1 generic "future/unknown axis" catch-all row (= 18 rows). The catch-all is required (it is what makes the model open); final wording states "17 enumerated + 1 open" explicitly. |
1.4 Answer to Success-Target Q1
"Has Round 3 actually resolved all Tier-1 wording blockers except substrate prerequisites?" → YES.
- T1-1 (Class 0 + shared-truth test) → M-DEF-1 ✅ wording.
- T1-2 (role taxonomy + responsibility scope, reconcile §4.12) → M-DEF-3 ✅ wording.
- T1-3 (exception/owner-path contradiction B5 + identity grain F1 + gate severity F3) → M-DEF-5/7 + severity-aware gate ✅ wording.
- T1-4 (inheritance owner-link-ONLY) → M-DEF-7 ✅ wording.
- T1-5 (birth↔governance dedup precedence) → M-DEF-4 ✅ wording.
- T1-7 (route registry / detection completeness) → derived-on-scan inventory, OQ-G1/G2 defaults ✅ wording.
- T1-6 (substrate): NOT a wording fix — APR action-types (T1-6a) + object/axis ownership edge §5.4-EXT (T1-6b) are genuine schema deltas, correctly reclassified as the single residual prerequisite. Round 4 adds a third substrate residual: SB-AXIS-ENVELOPE (the IU
iu_three_axis_envelopehardcodes exactly 3 axes — see doc 05/08).
So: all Tier-1 wording blockers are resolved; the only unresolved items are substrate prerequisites (T1-6a, T1-6b, SB-AXIS-ENVELOPE) and council/human decisions (OP-B, enactment) — exactly as a CONDITIONAL GO requires.
1.5 What must NOT be redone (anti-duplication)
The following are complete and authoritative — Round 4 verifies and references them, does not rebuild them: the federated-but-central model; the 12 gap types; the coverage accounting identity; M-DEF-1..9; the 13 object classes; the §0-GOV hook; the 9 Axis-Registry attributes; the recon/vector/relation IU invariants. Round 4's new work is confined to: open-question closure (doc 02), count>1 rule (doc 04), all-domain proof (doc 03), IU open-axis substrate evidence (doc 05), Đ37 centralization decision (doc 06), specialized-law matrix (doc 07), live-PG blocker list (doc 08), Red-Team v3 (doc 09), consolidated final text (doc 10).