KB-2920

13 — Self-Review & Acceptance

4 min read Revision 1
architecturediscoveryself-reviewacceptanceread-only

13 — Self-Review & Acceptance

Acceptance criteria (mission §11)

Criterion Met? Evidence
Mandatory laws searched/read OR NOT_FOUND with evidence doc 02 — all 15 located; Đ23/44/45 anomalies documented with exact paths/search terms
Law-to-capability matrix exists doc 03
Live PG capability inventory exists doc 04 (10 sections, live counts)
KB/design capability inventory exists doc 05 (10 clusters)
Anti-forgetting ledger exists doc 06 (searched/read/not-found/inspected + confidence)
Official list inventory exists doc 07 (15 lists)
DOT + UI Preview pilots deep enough docs 08, 09 (live numbers, function reality, verdicts)
Reuse-first plan avoids duplicate-new design doc 10 (REUSE/EXTEND/WRAP/RECONCILE/DEFER/NEW; NEW only where proven absent)
No mutation occurred see below

Verdict: PASS.

No-mutation attestation

  • All PG access via query_pg (AST-validated read-only role, READ ONLY tx, 5s timeout). Only SELECT (incl. information_schema, pg_catalog, pg_get_functiondef).
  • Volatile functions (pivot_count/query/matrix, refresh_*, fn_birth_gate, fn_pre_birth_check, fn_refresh_dot_count/orphan, test_counting_contract) inspected by definition only, never executed.
  • No Directus/Qdrant writes. No write_file/ingest_document. UI Preview Master accessed via HTTP GET only.
  • KB upload_document used solely to create this 13-doc report package (the permitted apply channel).
  • Baseline registry counts unchanged (no write path taken): information_unit 219, iu_relation 60, meta_catalog 169, collection_registry 168, dot_tools 309, normative_registry 47, governance_registry 9, approval_requests 211.

What this mission corrected vs prior memory

  1. Pivot+counting subsystem surfaced as a first-class, reusable engine (pivot_definitions 37, pivot_count/query/matrix, refresh_meta_catalog_from_pivot, v_registry_counts) — under-represented in prior memory; the key anti-forgetting win.
  2. normative_registry (47) is the law metadata SoT in PG (one agent initially mis-flagged it NOT_FOUND as a KB doc; reconciled).
  3. Đ23/Đ45 enacted but absent from normative_registry; law_catalog stale — concrete reconciliation targets.
  4. UI Preview Master live status = 61 items / status vocab not_started/cowork_sketch/spec_ready/preview_deployed (memory's deployed2/spec_ready4/idea13 was the older 19-surface set); review-log.md drifted.
  5. ui_pages (37) is a separate live PG UI inventory disjoint from the manifest — a reconciliation gap not previously noted.

Confidence & limitations

  • Domain confidence 0.78–0.95 (doc 06). Lowest: scanner/detector (signatures read, not all bodies) and IU profile (Đ44 DRAFT).
  • KB cluster 6 ("official/living list") and 10 ("normative_registry") returned no single canonical KB doc; resolved via PG ground truth.
  • Did not execute any list-count to "verify" pivots (would require running volatile fns) — counts taken from prior pivot_results/meta_catalog values and live SELECT counts, which agree with pivot ground truth (e.g. dot_tools 309 = PIV-007).

Package

knowledge/dev/reports/architecture/law-capability-discovery-official-lists-automation-2026-05-30/ — 13 docs (01–13).

Back to Knowledge Hub knowledge/dev/reports/architecture/law-capability-discovery-official-lists-automation-2026-05-30/13-self-review.md