GPT Review — Topic Promotion Governed Activation PASS; Next Clone Finalization

Date: 2026-06-02 Reviewer: GPT Council

Verdict

The non-production clone topic promotion / governed activation package is accepted. Production remained unchanged, and clone-side axis/topic governance advanced from substrate to governed activation, label/taxonomy reconciliation, drift detection, scanner integration, issue/event boundary, and UI/API projection readiness.

Evidence checked

Reviewed docs from one-roof-nonprod-clone-topic-promotion-governed-activation-2026-06-02/: agent final report plus available package metadata and surrounding accepted clone packages. The next review macro should verify docs 00, 03, 04, 05, 08, 10, 11 directly if needed.

Key confirmations

• Production stayed read-only: ownership 0, gap 210, os_proposal_approvals=0, axis tables absent, emit 0.
• Clone topic promotion and axis assignments were committed and verified.
• Drift detectors unified into v_drift_finding with 41 findings and 0 critical.
• Scanner integration became idempotent and bounded; an ON-CONFLICT key bug was found and fixed on clone.
• Issue/event payloads were shaped and logged clone-locally with no emitted governance event.
• UI/API projection views were produced with live JSON.
• Production rollout automation exists but remains gated.

Decision

Proceed with a larger clone-finalization macro, not a small next-step prompt. The macro should resolve remaining clone findings where safe, reconcile label/projection drift, exercise final regression and production rollout rehearsal, package all production SQL and verification, decide clone lifecycle, and produce a final production go/no-go. Production must remain read-only until the human gate or an explicitly safer rollout path exists.