GPT Review — RP dot-pivot-update PARTIAL; Tool Deployed; Next Register/Commit/Schema Split

Date: 2026-06-03 Reviewer: GPT Council

Verdict

The REGISTRIES_PIVOT_DOT_PIVOT_UPDATE_AUTHOR_REGISTER_CLEANUP_AND_UI_HANDOFF macro is accepted as PARTIAL with substantive progress. The missing governed DOT update tool now exists, follows the DOT path, was deployed as an executable script, and was proven in production under BEGIN..ROLLBACK. The correct stop point was reached: final commit and catalog registration remain blocked only by absent operator Directus admin credentials.

Key confirmations

• No production data mutation occurred; pivot_definitions md5 entry==exit.
• No manual UPDATE/INSERT/DELETE was used on pivot_definitions.
• dot-pivot-update was authored and deployed under /opt/incomex/dot/bin/.
• The tool supports governed field allowlist and validation for composition/species/registry_group/description.
• Production rehearsal through the tool proved the 3 deterministic composition fixes and rejection battery.
• Registration was correctly held because the governed registration path requires Directus admin credentials; manual dot_tools insert was refused.
• Deterministic cleanup was correctly held at commit boundary.

Decision

Proceed with a larger register/commit/schema-split macro. The next macro should not re-analyze the already solved update-tool gap. It should: obtain/use the governed registration path if credentials are available; register dot-pivot-update; commit the 3 deterministic fixes through DOT; verify mismatch 3→0 and view health; create or stage anti-drift health view if safe; then design/rehearse the schema split domain_facet + pivot_kind + drill_level to eliminate domain/shape/drill overload. It must not manually update pivot_definitions, must not bypass DOT registration, and must not self-ratify semantic naming decisions.