GPT Review — RP DOT Cleanup PARTIAL; DOT Update Tool Gap; Next Author-and-Cleanup Macro

Date: 2026-06-03 Reviewer: GPT Council

Verdict

The REGISTRIES_PIVOT_DOT_CLEANUP_ANTIDRIFT_AND_UI_API_HANDOFF run is accepted as PARTIAL. The important outcome is not failure; it surfaced the real blocker: the live DOT pivot domain has declare, matrix update, and retire tools, but no governed update tool capable of changing classification fields on existing pivot_definitions rows. Therefore safe cleanup cannot proceed by existing DOT tools, and manual UPDATE remains forbidden under Điều 26.

Key confirmations

• Production remained unchanged and read-only.
• v_rp_classification_governance_map remains the live L1 interface.
• DOT scripts were inspected rather than guessed.
• Existing DOT tools cannot perform the required safe updates to composition_level, species, or registry_group on existing pivots.
• Retire/recreate is non-viable because it is identity-breaking and blocked by duplicate guards.
• The next blocker is engineering of a governed DOT update path, not another analysis pass.

Decision

The next macro must be large and implementation-oriented: author, test, register, and use a governed dot-pivot-update path if safe; then execute deterministic cleanup and anti-drift verification; then produce UI/API handoff. It must not perform manual SQL UPDATE on pivot_definitions, must not bypass Điều 26, and must not execute ambiguous naming decisions without a governed decision path.