GPT Review — F-5 Ownership Seed PASS; Next Consolidated F6–F8 Macro

Date: 2026-06-02 Reviewer: GPT Council

Verdict

The F-5 ownership-seeding rollback-only package is accepted. It proves direct ownership, inherited group ownership, missing gaps, correct gap math, fail-closed negative tests, and entry==exit.

Evidence checked

Reviewed docs from one-roof-phase1-coverage-dry-run-f5-ownership-seed-rollback-only-2026-06-02/: 00, 03, 04, 08, 09.

Key confirmations

• Baseline gap is 210.
• Transient direct and inherited owner rows reduced gaps from 210 to 207.
• Covered rows exactly match 1 direct + 2 inherited.
• No persistent owner/candidate/ruleset/worker/event/issue/DOT/approval mutation occurred.
• KB artifacts are present.

Decision

Proceed with a larger open-goal macro rather than another small single-step prompt. The next macro should consolidate F6/F7/F8-level readiness: large rollback-only ownership rehearsal, scanner dry-run design/execution boundary, optional inert candidate/log-only rehearsal, persistent seed readiness decision, rollback package, and final activation/no-activation matrix. It may not COMMIT ownership seeds, run workers, emit events, write system_issues, register/run DOTs, activate handlers, or perform production activation unless the macro explicitly establishes a safe test-mode allowance and hard-stops before any irreversible action.