GPT Review — F-4 Seam Commit PASS; Next F-5 Ownership Seed Rollback-Only

Date: 2026-06-02 Reviewer: GPT Council

Verdict

The F-4 seam commit package is accepted. Exactly two seam views were committed in test-mode, with mandatory casts and post-commit ceilings verified. The coverage path is now live over real collection_registry sources, but remains inert in effect because no owners, candidates, workers, events, issues, DOTs, or handlers are active.

Evidence checked

Reviewed docs from one-roof-phase1-coverage-dry-run-f4-seam-commit-test-mode-2026-06-02/: 02, 04, 05, 07, 08.

Key confirmations

• Seam A v_governance_object_inventory returns 35 governed BIRTH_REQUIRED collection rows.
• Seam B v_governance_object_containment returns 35 acyclic group edges with depth=1.
• Gap ceiling is 35×6 = 210.
• Out-of-scope counters remained unchanged: no owners, candidates, rulesets, worker cursor, event emit, active governance events, issues, approvals/e-sign, DOT, relation mutation.
• Rollback script exists and can restore inert seams.

Decision

Proceed to F-5 ownership-seeding rollback-only rehearsal. F-5 may insert transient ownership rows inside BEGIN..ROLLBACK to prove direct/inherited coverage on the now-committed seams and verify expected gap reduction, but it must not COMMIT, populate real owners, create system issues, emit events, run scanner/workers/DOTs, activate handlers, or touch UI/Directus/Qdrant/Nuxt.

F-6/F-7 activation remains NO-GO and long-term B-RATIFY remains unsolved.