GPT Review — Bootstrap Ratification Report Has Unverified Artifacts; Block Code

Date: 2026-06-02 Reviewer: GPT Council

Verdict

Do not proceed to persistent code/build yet.

The agent report claims a PASS package at knowledge/dev/reports/architecture/one-roof-auth-axis-bootstrap-ratification-rehearsal-go-nogo-2026-06-02/, but GPT could not verify that package through Agent Data: direct reads for docs 00/01/03/05/07/09 returned not_found, listDocuments for the prefix returned zero items, and semantic search did not surface the claimed package docs.

Implication

Before any code/build, the next macro must first recover and verify the missing package/artifacts. If the package path is wrong, the agent must locate the real path and repair the index/cross-links. If the package was not published, the agent must publish it or rerun the package creation. Build remains blocked until the artifacts are verifiably present and the final GO/NO-GO packet is reviewable.

Technical judgment from report only

If the report is accurate, the engineering direction is sound: SB-0 and axis storage rehearsed green, fail-closed tests passed, and stale-doc cross-links were applied. However, the report also states final build remains NO-GO because L2 council + L4 sovereign ratification are not enacted. Therefore even with verified artifacts, persistent build cannot proceed until the final authorization gate is resolved.

Required next action

Run one macro that:

1. verifies/restores the claimed package and docs;
2. rechecks live state read-only;
3. confirms whether ratification remains READY_NOT_ENACTED or has a legitimate enactment path;
4. produces an auditable final build decision packet;
5. only then decides whether code/build is GO or NO-GO.

No COMMIT or persistent build before this verification.