GPT Review — Bootstrap Artifacts Verified; GO to Ratification Intake

Date: 2026-06-02 Reviewer: GPT Council

Verdict

The rerun/publish/verify mission is accepted. The bootstrap artifact-integrity blocker is closed. Persistent build remains NO-GO. The correct next step is ratification intake for the authorization model and SB-0 adoption.

Evidence checked

Reviewed package docs 00, 03, 05, 06, 07, and 09 at: knowledge/dev/reports/architecture/one-roof-auth-axis-bootstrap-ratification-rehearsal-go-nogo-2026-06-02/

The package is now readable from KB and includes the prior missing evidence: state recovery, live SB-0 rehearsal, fail-closed tests, stale-doc cross-links, final GO/NO-GO, and self-review.

Key confirmations

• Prior FS-only artifact problem is fixed.
• SB-0 and axis substrate rehearsal is REHEARSED-GREEN under BEGIN..ROLLBACK.
• Fail-closed/anti-forgery behavior is proven at rehearsal level.
• Cross-links were applied and documented.
• Final build decision is honest: GO_TO_RATIFICATION_INTAKE, persistent BUILD NO-GO.
• No persistent PG mutation, COMMIT, approval/e-sign, event/DOT, Directus/Qdrant/Nuxt, law/version/status mutation occurred.

Remaining blocker

The remaining blocker is not engineering evidence. It is ratification/enactment of the new authorization model:

• D-BOOT-1: redefine M-1 to SB-0 per-step technical build authorization.
• D-BOOT-2: adopt SB-0 as L3 technical build gate; reserve os_proposal_approvals for L4 sovereign e-sign only.

Decision

Proceed to one large ratification-intake macro. The macro should prepare the ratification artifact and, if allowed by the live governance substrate, record it through legitimate decision/approval channels. It must not forge e-signature, must not self-approve, and must not build persistent substrate unless ratification is legitimate and explicit.