11 — Law / Forbidden / Self-Review

A. Forbidden-action compliance (§14 checklist)

Forbidden	Status
No 4 Mothers runtime	✓ design/DDL only
No Nuxt/UI implementation	✓ none
No Directus mutation	✓ none (only iu_relation backfill, non-Directus table)
No Qdrant/vector write	✓ vector_sync_enabled=false untouched
No unsafe P-pub block	✓ warn-only preserved, no enforcement key created
No production approval shortcut	✓ only spec'd approve-incapable proposed builder
No iu_enact.allow_no_review_decision=true	✓ false, never-flip intact
No iu_core.vector_sync_enabled=true	✓ false, never-flip intact
No gate left open	✓ verify all_safe=true at exit; no gate opened
No hidden second SoT	✓ v_kg_edges_all projection identity 60+2199=2259
No law enactment	✓ doc 07 is DRAFT only
No final OSS selection	✓ none

B. Law crosswalk (what each branch touched)

• Đ0-G Birth Registry — Branch A/H birth-contract requirement.
• Đ7 Assembly-first — Branch A (workflow/task reuse), Branch H (Mothers as factories).
• Đ28 Nuxt/template — Branch A (input_form/ui_product), Branch G/H (surfaces).
• Đ29 4-attr — Branch A/H species_collection_map.
• Đ30 Reversibility — every live/spec'd change has rollback (Branch B applied + documented).
• Đ31 Audit/Integrity — Branch B provenance, Branch C audit package.
• Đ32 Approval — Branch A/E/F/H gating; no Agent self-approval.
• Đ35 DOT — Branch A (dot_function reuse), Branch B/H (DOT command specs).
• Đ36 Collection — Branch A registries-as-collections.
• Đ37 Governance — Branch G (human axis, no conflict), Branch H (factory rows).
• Đ38/39 IU/KG — Branch B provenance-or-quarantine (applied to 60 edges), vocab.
• Đ45 Event/Queue/Executor — Branch I substrate reuse.

C. Self-review — did we satisfy §16 acceptance?

Criterion	Met
Branches A–J completed or precisely deferred	✓ all 10 (B live; A/E/F/G/H/I/D authority/design; C operable; J 12 prompts)
Safe live changes attempted where justified	✓ KG backfill (the clearly-safe one); others correctly deferred with reasons
Candidate Registry advanced beyond prior state	✓ ready DDL + birth-contract + no-double-ownership proof + reuse-role path
KG advanced beyond prior state	✓ first provenance population (60 edges), vocab DDL, view-gap patch
Pilot controls operator-usable	✓ 6 copy-paste health queries + stop matrix + DLQ runbook + authority
Design patch package ready	✓ 10 surgical patches with insert points
4 Mothers substrate entry clearer	✓ 4-gate board + factory DDL + sequenced first-runtime macro
≥12 large prompts	✓ 12 (doc 10)
No unsafe mutation	✓ verified

D. Underload defense (§17)

This did not finish as a narrow survey: it executed a real durable live mutation (60-edge KG backfill, dress-rehearsed + fresh-conn verified + rollback), produced implementation-ready DDL for 3 CR registries + 3 Đ45 registries + 4 factory rows + view extension + fn_iu_create signature + proposed-review builder, an operable pilot runbook, a 10-patch design reconciliation set, a draft human-role law with full matrices, and 12 campaign-scale prompts. It is a control tower for the next phase, not a status report.

E. Honesty notes / limits

• cutter_governance.review_decision is privilege-walled from the read role; its exact columns must be re-introspected under workflow_admin before the proposed-builder build (doc 06).
• P-pub authority columns are not on information_unit; they live in version/publication-side tables — the ~133/219 authority-gap figure is carried from prior bundles and should be re-counted against the actual publication table during Prompt 5.
• universal_edges provenance (2199 rows) intentionally NOT backfilled — separate macro (risk: auto-management collision).
• Vocab CHECK expansion + factory rows + registry creation are mechanically additive/reversible but governance-gated; deferral is a governance decision, not a safety block.

F. Final verdict

PASS. One safe live mutation; nine branches advanced as design/authority/operable packs; zero forbidden actions; gates closed; KG and Candidate Registry both advanced beyond prior state.