KB-6816 rev 2

fix7-p0-dryrun-precondition-recheck-2026-06-11.json

5 min read Revision 2

{ "doc": "fix7-p0-dryrun-precondition-recheck", "date": "2026-06-11", "authority_of_this_doc": "DRYRUN_NON_AUTHORITY; re-evaluates the 12 planning preconditions under owner AUTHORIZE_DRYRUN_ONLY", "dryrun_can_proceed": true, "execution_ready": false, "items": [ {"id": "PC-1", "precondition": "Codex seal complete (N7/N8/P7; P7 pins rev3)", "planning_status": "PASS", "recheck_classification": "PASS", "evidence": "3 node files byte-exact; seal tree 3890cd34..a234 recomputed match; logs/A_verify_inputs.log", "dryrun_impact": "enables", "execution_impact": "required PASS"}, {"id": "PC-2", "precondition": "Owner OPT-4 execution approval", "planning_status": "FAIL", "recheck_classification": "BLOCKS_EXECUTION_ONLY", "evidence": "owner gave AUTHORIZE_DRYRUN_ONLY, not OPT-4/execution; FIX7-P0-PLAN-EXEC-AUTH-1 still open", "dryrun_impact": "does not block dry-run", "execution_impact": "blocks execution"}, {"id": "PC-3", "precondition": "Seal-vs-bytes recheck (canon rev3 == P7 pin)", "planning_status": "UNKNOWN", "recheck_classification": "PASS", "evidence": "DR-1 RAN: fresh-fetched canon rev3 -> measured 38756 utf8 bytes, sha256 49c386a9..b734d0 == P7 pin (exact); logs/DR1_seal_vs_bytes.log", "dryrun_impact": "PASS (now executed)", "execution_impact": "must be re-run at execution start"}, {"id": "PC-4", "precondition": "Allowed mutations enumerated (default deny)", "planning_status": "PASS", "recheck_classification": "PASS", "evidence": "planning mutation-inventory.json 10 surfaces all allowed_now=false", "dryrun_impact": "enables", "execution_impact": "required PASS"}, {"id": "PC-5", "precondition": "Forbidden mutations standing", "planning_status": "PASS", "recheck_classification": "PASS", "evidence": "forbidden surfaces inventoried; no PG/Directus/system_issues command issued this dry-run", "dryrun_impact": "enables", "execution_impact": "required PASS"}, {"id": "PC-6", "precondition": "Rollback verified before apply", "planning_status": "UNKNOWN", "recheck_classification": "PASS", "evidence": "DR-2/3/4 staging mutations + RB-2/RB-3/RB-4 rollback PROVEN_IN_STAGING with before/after hashes; logs/DR2_DR3_DR4_rollback.log", "dryrun_impact": "PASS (proven in staging)", "execution_impact": "production rollback still needs separate proof"}, {"id": "PC-7", "precondition": "REAL_RUN separate approval", "planning_status": "FAIL", "recheck_classification": "BLOCKS_EXECUTION_ONLY", "evidence": "not granted; not requested or invoked this dry-run; FIX7-P0-PLAN-REALRUN-1", "dryrun_impact": "does not block dry-run (REAL_RUN not part of dry-run)", "execution_impact": "blocks execution"}, {"id": "PC-8", "precondition": "QT001/apply/permit/activation/repoint/cutover each separate", "planning_status": "FAIL", "recheck_classification": "BLOCKS_EXECUTION_ONLY", "evidence": "none granted; none requested/invoked; FIX7-P0-PLAN-SEPARATE-AUTH-1", "dryrun_impact": "does not block dry-run", "execution_impact": "blocks execution"}, {"id": "PC-9", "precondition": "Evidence discipline (no fake PASS)", "planning_status": "PASS", "recheck_classification": "PASS", "evidence": "this packet's commands.sh/RERUN.sh/exit_codes.json executed; every gate shows real output", "dryrun_impact": "enables", "execution_impact": "required PASS"}, {"id": "PC-10", "precondition": "Governance (no orphan)", "planning_status": "PASS", "recheck_classification": "PASS", "evidence": "governance-objects.json TKT-OBJ-389..406 via standalone addendum (deconflicted from 378..395 after concurrent T2 378..388); collision scan 0", "dryrun_impact": "enables", "execution_impact": "required PASS"}, {"id": "PC-11", "precondition": "First-step readback before any mutation", "planning_status": "UNKNOWN", "recheck_classification": "PASS", "evidence": "DR-0 (validator readback) + DR-1 (seal-vs-bytes) ran BEFORE DR-2/3/4 staging mutations; ordered in dryrun-execution-evidence.json", "dryrun_impact": "PASS (demonstrated)", "execution_impact": "must repeat at execution start"}, {"id": "PC-12", "precondition": "Production surface fully scoped (no UNKNOWN production surface)", "planning_status": "UNKNOWN", "recheck_classification": "BLOCKS_EXECUTION_ONLY", "evidence": "production birth surface (#5) + CI (#10) still UNKNOWN; no Directus/PG read performed; FIX7-P0-PLAN-SURFACE-1/2. Dry-run is staging-only so this does not block the dry-run.", "dryrun_impact": "does not block dry-run (staging-only)", "execution_impact": "blocks execution"} ], "summary": { "PASS": 8, "BLOCKS_EXECUTION_ONLY": 4, "BLOCKS_DRYRUN": 0, "FAIL": 0, "UNKNOWN": 0, "DRYRUN_ALLOWED_WITH_LIMIT": 0 }, "conclusion": "No precondition BLOCKS_DRYRUN. The staging-only dry-run proceeded safely. PC-2/PC-7/PC-8/PC-12 remain BLOCKS_EXECUTION_ONLY -> a future execution macro is still blocked until owner OPT-4 + production scoping + separate REAL_RUN/QT001/cutover grants." }