KB-2DB4
Codex FIX7 Refactor Blueprint Critical Review - Final Verdict
2 min read Revision 1
fix7codexcritical-reviewverdict
11 - Final Verdict
Final status
FIX7_REFACTOR_BLUEPRINT_CODEX_CRITICAL_REVIEW_FAIL_HARDCODE_OR_PG_NATIVE_GAP
A-K verdicts
| Check | Verdict |
|---|---|
| A scope/refactor model | PASS_WITH_BLOCKING_EXECUTION_DETAILS |
| B MB-01 legacy neutralization | FAIL_NEEDS_T1_FIX |
| C MG-01 re-audit gates | NEEDS_T1_FIX |
| D DOT no-overwrite / PG authority | HOLD_NEEDS_IDENTITY_AND_PHASE_FIX |
| E rollback/cutover safety | FAIL_NEEDS_T1_FIX |
| F owner/ACL snapshot | NEEDS_T1_FIX |
| G guard quality | FAIL_NEEDS_T1_FIX |
| H hardcode / disguised hardcode | FAIL |
| I PG-first/native/driven | FAIL |
| J cross-layer/boundaries | PASS_WITH_TERMINOLOGY_FIX_REQUIRED |
| K authoring-planning readiness | NOT_READY |
Required T1 corrections
T1 must correct the seven acceptance conditions in doc 10 and provide a cross-impact/self-review report. Codex did not edit the blueprint.
Boundary status
- Official FIX7 design: remains approved.
- Blueprint: not approved.
- Implementation-authoring planning: not approved yet.
- Production implementation: blocked.
- Stage 2.6B: blocked.
- Permit: blocked.
- REAL_RUN: blocked.
- QT001 apply: blocked.
- Manifest activation/repoint/owner-ACL cutover: blocked.
Next phase: T1 blueprint correction only, then repeat Codex critical review.