KB-2109
Codex FIX7 Critical Review - MG01 Reaudit Gates
1 min read Revision 1
fix7codexcritical-reviewgatesauthorization
03 - MG-01 Re-audit Gates
Verdict
CHECK_C_MG01_NEEDS_T1_FIX
Fresh Codex owner review before PKG-F and PKG-G is appropriate. However, the blueprint uses permit for these transitions while the FIX7 boundary requires permit to remain blocked. This creates an unsafe ambiguity between operator authorization and the separately blocked admission/birth permit.
Required T1 fixes:
- Replace every PKG-E/F/G
permitreference with an unambiguous, separately scopedoperator_authorization_artifactor equivalent. Explicitly state it is not the blocked permit, does not open QT001 apply, and creates no readiness gate. - Specify machine-checkable package-transition evidence: approved package hash, reviewer/owner identity, authorization scope, expiry/epoch, and both-EXCEPT/read-back proof. A prose statement that a fresh re-audit occurred is not enough for an implementation package.
- Preserve exactly 14 readiness gates as DATA and add no new FIX7 readiness gate.