KB-7351
Codex FIX7 Recheck 2 - Legacy Denominator
2 min read Revision 1
fix7codexrecheck-2legacy-denominatorhardcode
02 - Legacy Denominator Recheck
Verdict
LEGACY_DENOMINATOR_FAIL
U_legacy improves coverage by adding reverse write-effect closure, executable entrypoints, and entry vectors. It is still not a closed independent denominator:
- The roots are described as “20 legacy qt001 tables”, QT001 apply objects, and birth/permit resources. The blueprint does not specify the independent sealed PG authority that selects these roots without name/manual inventory.
- “Every legacy routine with effective EXECUTE” uses the term being derived, making the rule circular unless the universe of routines is independently defined.
- DO_NOT_TOUCH is subtracted by sealed identity, but the approved PG surface holding that exclusion set and its exact proof is not identified.
- Scheduler/frozen-DOT entry-vector derivation and analyzer output bindings are not specified as an exact, fail-closed PG set.
Required T1 fix: define independent typed root and exclusion sets, exact analyzer contract/output rows, closure direction, unsupported/dynamic-call failure behavior, and both-EXCEPT queries. The output sealed set cannot also be the unproven input roots.