KB-7B53
Orchestrator O2 · 07 Final Report (Result A ORCHESTRATOR_O2_E2E_AUTHORING_PASS)
10 min read Revision 1
dot-iu-cutterv0.6orchestrator-o2-phase-body-e2e-authoringfinal-reportresult-aorchestrator-o2-e2e-authoring-passstop-route-gpt-userxhigh-effortdieu442026-05-20
Orchestrator O2 · 07 Final Report — ORCHESTRATOR_O2_E2E_AUTHORING_PASS
doc 7 of 7 · 2026-05-20 · STOP gate
outcome : A — ORCHESTRATOR_O2_E2E_AUTHORING_PASS production_mutation : NONE stop_route : GPT / User
1. Outcome
Result A — ORCHESTRATOR_O2_E2E_AUTHORING_PASS. The v0.6
one-command automation orchestrator now has every phase body filled
against an in-process simulator, every gate invariant predicate
implemented, and a 51-test end-to-end suite that walks the full state
machine through both sovereign gates to closeout — all without
touching Postgres, the network, or any secret. The production
execution kill-switch remains False. Main remains at 35ca9e1.
commit : 4649423 on feature/constitution-snapshot-mark-dryrun
parent : 35ca9e1
files_changed : 22 (16 modified + 4 new tests + 2 updated O1 tests)
lines_added : +2086
lines_removed : -226
discover : 359/359 PASS (was 308; +51 new tests; 0 regressions)
production_mutation : NONE
deploy/push/tag : NONE
feature_head_after : 4649423
main_head_after : 35ca9e1 (UNCHANGED)
__execution_enabled__: False (unchanged)
__milestone__ : O1 → O2
2. Gate roll-up
| Gate | Subject | Outcome | KB doc |
|---|---|---|---|
| G0 | SSOT + repo precheck + ruling acceptance | PASS | doc 01 |
| G1 | O1 code survey + 6 O2 gap identification | PASS | doc 01 |
| G2 | Phase body implementation (11/11 bodies filled) | PASS | doc 02 |
| G3 | Gate invariant predicates (41/41 predicates filled) | PASS | doc 03 |
| G4 | In-memory E2E tests (51 new tests) | PASS | doc 04 |
| G5 | Hardcode / security / boundary audit | PASS | doc 05 |
| G6 | Test suite — 359/359 full discover | PASS | doc 04 |
| G7 | Local commit (no push, no tag, no main FF) | PASS | doc 06 + this |
3. Authored surface — at-a-glance
package_LOC:
pre_O2_total : 1741 LOC (O1 closeout)
o2_added : +1226 LOC
o2_total : 2967 LOC
phase_body_LOC_breakdown (modified files only):
source_pin : unchanged (already functional in O1)
mark : +75 LOC — region_sha derivation, cap enforcement
cutplan : +94 LOC — two-pass determinism, vocab coverage
pre_write_backup : +48 LOC — DRYRUN marker
grant_probe : +34 LOC — 4-bit matrix audit
cut_leg_a : +82 LOC — SG_1 evidence, fan-out simulator
structural_verify : +44 LOC — 11-bool probe
leg_b_record : +57 LOC — deterministic envelope ids
write_verify : +61 LOC — G-VERIFY-ONCE
lifecycle_enact : +86 LOC — SG_2 evidence, fan-out enact
closeout : +45 LOC — pre-req audit, runs-index append
infrastructure_LOC:
discover.py : +233 LOC — 4 dataclasses + 8 simulator methods
gates.py : +170 LOC — 41 predicates, 6 closure helpers
runner.py : +130 LOC — resume handshake, drift recheck,
generic-exception trap, stop-doc upload
run_context.py : +4 LOC — consumed_approval_ids field
state_store.py : +12 LOC — enum-aware restore
__init__.py : +13 LOC — milestone tag, banner
test_surface:
_orchestrator_o2_harness.py : 119 LOC (NEW, shared)
test_orchestrator_o2_e2e.py : 179 LOC, 12 tests (NEW)
test_orchestrator_o2_gate_invariants.py : 186 LOC, 18 tests (NEW)
test_orchestrator_o2_phase_bodies.py : 143 LOC, 21 tests (NEW)
test_orchestrator_o1_runner.py : ±7 LOC (O2-reality update)
test_orchestrator_o1_state_machine.py : ±15 LOC (milestone-tag update)
total_new_test_loc : 627 + 119 harness
4. Cross-cutting invariants — enforced AND tested in O2
| # | Invariant | Where enforced | Where tested |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | No user artifact (digests/secrets/IDs) | policy.assert_no_user_artifact (unchanged) |
TestNoUserArtifactPolicy (O1) + USER_REFUSED_ARGS audit (G5) |
| 2 | No module-level PIN_* in orchestrator | static (no PIN_ symbols authored) + assert_no_module_level_pins |
TestNoModuleLevelPins (O1) + TestRegistryShape + audit (G5) |
| 3 | Secret-shaped pin keys refused/stripped | RunContext.pin() + to_jsonable() |
TestPerRunContextPins (O1) |
| 4 | Live mode refused while killswitch off | __execution_enabled__ = False + 6 guards (1 runner + 1 backup + 4 mutating phases) |
TestLiveModeRefused (O1) + TestKillSwitchOff (O2) + per-phase test_live_mode_refused (O2) |
| 5 | No silent retry of unwritten predicates | evaluate_internal raises StopInvariantFailed on NotImplementedError |
TestRegistryShape.test_no_invariant_is_still_a_todo_o2 |
| 6 | Sovereign authority preservation | SG_2 requires fresh review_decision_id; TTLs enforced; consumed_approval_ids refuses replay |
TestApprovalValidation (O1) + TestApprovalConsumedExactlyOnce (O2) |
| 7 | Batch lane safety (no duplicate prefix) | queue loader refuses | TestBatchQueueLoader.test_refuses_duplicate_document_id (O1) |
| 8 | KB upload is green-light gate | DryRunReporter raises StopKbUploadFailed on write failure |
TestKBArtifactsWrittenForEachPhase (O2 — every phase emits a doc) |
| 9 | Drift refusal mid-pause | runner._assert_no_drift on resume | TestStopDriftOnResume (O2) |
| 10 | Stop-doc upload on every error route | runner._finalize_stop | TestUnknownDocumentStop (O2) |
| 11 | Generic exception → clean stop_code | runner._drive exception wrapping | TestDryRunSourcePinPasses (O2-updated O1 test) |
5. State after this macro
repo_root : /Users/nmhuyen/iu-cutter-build/repo/iu-cutter
branch_checkout : feature/constitution-snapshot-mark-dryrun
feature_head : 4649423
main_head : 35ca9e1 (UNCHANGED — no FF this macro)
divergence : 1 commit ahead, 0 behind
working_tree : clean
remote : absent
tags : none
__execution_enabled__ : False
__milestone__ : O2
__version__ : 0.6.0-O2-phase-body-e2e
pytest_full_discover : 359/359 PASS
6. KB folder index
knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.6-orchestrator-o2-phase-body-e2e-authoring/
01-ssot-repo-and-o1-survey-2026-05-20.md02-phase-body-implementation-summary-2026-05-20.md03-gate-invariants-summary-2026-05-20.md04-in-memory-e2e-test-result-2026-05-20.md05-security-hardcode-boundary-check-2026-05-20.md06-git-status-commit-result-2026-05-20.md07-final-o2-authoring-report-2026-05-20.md(this)
Folder convention preserved (knowledge/dev/laws/<doc-id>/<macro>/).
7. Forbidden surface — final attestation
| Forbidden | Status |
|---|---|
| Production mutation | NOT DONE |
| Live CUT / VERIFY / enact | NOT DONE |
| execution_enabled flipped | NOT DONE |
| Live orchestrator execution | NOT DONE |
| Deploy / restart | NOT DONE |
| Push / tag remote | NOT DONE |
| Source_document mutation | NOT DONE |
| source_version mutation | NOT DONE |
| Hardcode secrets / runtime IDs | NOT DONE |
| StubSigning → real crypto | NOT DONE (deferred to O6) |
| FF main without approval | NOT DONE (main UNCHANGED at 35ca9e1) |
| Fake-PASS on un-evidenced gate | NOT DONE (predicates fail-closed) |
| v0.5 production module touched | NOT DONE |
8. Authorized next macros (sovereign-sequenced)
PATH_FF_O2_TO_MAIN (recommended next, trivial):
type : repo hygiene fast-forward
scope : git checkout main && git merge --ff-only feature/...
reason : same canonical 3-step FF pattern as
M4-FF / DDL-FF / MAIN-FF-AFTER-DDL-RATIFY /
MAIN-FF-AFTER-HARDCODE-CLEANLINESS / MAIN-FF-AFTER-O1
feasibility : 1 ↔ 0 linear (feature 1 ahead of main, 0 behind)
effort : single-line sovereign approval
PATH_O3_LIVE_DRY_RUN (alternative):
type : design + wiring authoring against real psycopg
under read-only credentials
scope : add a LiveDiscoverer (reads pg_proc, source_version,
grant matrix); orchestrator.cut still refuses
Mode.LIVE writes; first real source_pin/mark on
live Constitution.
effort : high
prereq : O1+O2 on main (PATH_FF_O2_TO_MAIN first)
PATH_R2 (separate, paired):
- B-TAG-V0_5 + B-REMOTE-CONFIG-PUSH (deferred backlog)
PATH_R4 (separate):
- contabo v0.5 deployment (orchestrator NOT yet bundled)
amend_O2 (if design gap surfaces in review):
- rev 2+ of this macro with the same gates
drop (not recommended):
- skip O2, jump to PATH_R3/R4
9. STOP
This macro halts here. Routing back to GPT / User.
final_outcome : A — ORCHESTRATOR_O2_E2E_AUTHORING_PASS
next_action : STOP → GPT / User