Orchestrator O1 · 06 Final Report — ORCHESTRATOR_O1_AUTHORING_PASS

doc 6 of 6 · 2026-05-20 · STOP gate

outcome              : A — ORCHESTRATOR_O1_AUTHORING_PASS
production_mutation  : NONE
stop_route           : GPT / User

1. Outcome

Result A — ORCHESTRATOR_O1_AUTHORING_PASS. The v0.6 one-command automation orchestrator skeleton is in place at commit 35ca9e1 on feature/constitution-snapshot-mark-dryrun. All 11 phases, 14 gates, 14 states, 17 STOP codes, and the cross-cutting policy hooks have authored contracts and test coverage. No live execution; no production touched; no v0.5-ratified module modified.

commit               : 35ca9e1 on feature (parent 0a64a61)
files_added          : 28 (24 orchestrator + 4 tests)
lines_added          : 2256 (+ 1741 orchestrator + 515 tests)
discover             : 308/308 PASS  (was 265; +43 new tests)
production_mutation  : NONE
deploy/push/tag      : NONE
feature_head_after   : 35ca9e1
main_head_after      : 0a64a61 (UNCHANGED)

2. Gate roll-up

Gate	Subject	Outcome	KB doc
G0	SSOT + repo precheck	PASS	doc 01
G1	Module placement decision	PASS	doc 02
G2	Contracts & skeleton authoring	PASS	doc 03
G3	Tests + static checks	PASS	doc 04
G4	No-execution boundary	PASS	doc 05
G5	Commit + KB reports	PASS	doc 05 + this

3. Authored surface — at-a-glance

state_machine:
  states                : 14 + 3 terminal categories
  forward_edges         : 13 (acyclic; ends at CLOSEOUT_REPORTED)
  sovereign_pause_states: 2

gates:
  internal_gates : 11 (one per phase) + invariant registry
  sovereign_gates: 3 (SG_1 cut authz, SG_2 lifecycle authz, SG_3 fail)

phases:
  total                  : 11
  functional_in_o1       : 1 (source_pin — read-only)
  skeleton_in_o1         : 10
  mutating_phase_guards  : 4 (raise ProductionExecutionNotAuthorized)

policy_hooks:
  no_user_artifact       : USER_REFUSED_ARGS frozenset of 20 names
  hardcode_safe          : RunContext.pin() refuses secret-shaped keys
                            + JSON output strip
                            + tests scan 11 modules for PIN_* leak
  discover_first         : Discoverer Protocol + InMemoryDiscoverer
  survey_first           : Discoverer methods are all read-only

persistence:
  sidecar_per_run        : ${CUTTER_RUNS_DIR}/<run_id>/state.json
  lock                   : fcntl.LOCK_EX | LOCK_NB
  atomicity              : tempfile + os.replace

approval:
  validate_sovereign_approval : parses KB doc; checks gate/run_id/
                                allowance/signed_utc/TTL
  sg2_review_decision_id      : REQUIRED (Phase 7 doctrine)
  ttls                        : SG_1 24h ; SG_2 12h

batch:
  queue_loader_validates : 5 invariants (schema_version, batch_id,
                            non-empty items, ≤ 100 items,
                            duplicate-prefix refusal)

tests:
  total_new        : 43
  full_discover    : 308/308 OK
  regressions      : 0

4. Cross-cutting invariants — enforced AND tested

#	Invariant	Where enforced	Where tested
1	No user artifact (digests/secrets/IDs)	policy.assert_no_user_artifact	TestNoUserArtifactPolicy
2	No module-level PIN_* in orchestrator	static (no PIN_ symbols authored) + assert_no_module_level_pins	TestNoModuleLevelPins
3	Secret-shaped pin keys refused/stripped	RunContext.pin() + to_jsonable()	TestPerRunContextPins
4	Live mode refused in O1	__execution_enabled__ = False + 4 phase guards + runner	TestLiveModeRefused
5	No silent retry of unwritten invariants	evaluate_internal converts NotImplementedError → StopInvariantFailed	(smoke-tested indirectly)
6	Sovereign authority preservation	SG_2 requires fresh review_decision_id; TTLs enforced	TestApprovalValidation
7	Batch lane safety (no duplicate prefix)	queue loader refuses	TestBatchQueueLoader.test_refuses_duplicate_document_id
8	KB upload is green-light gate	DryRunReporter raises StopKbUploadFailed on write failure	(architectural — exercised by sovereign-pause path)

5. State after this macro

repo_root          : /Users/nmhuyen/iu-cutter-build/repo/iu-cutter
branch_checkout    : feature/constitution-snapshot-mark-dryrun
feature_head       : 35ca9e1
main_head          : 0a64a61  (UNCHANGED)
divergence         : 1 commit ahead, 0 behind
working_tree       : clean
remote             : absent
tags               : none
__execution_enabled__ : False

6. KB folder index

knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.6-orchestrator-o1-authoring/

1. 01-ssot-and-repo-precheck-2026-05-20.md
2. 02-module-placement-decision-2026-05-20.md
3. 03-contracts-and-skeleton-summary-2026-05-20.md
4. 04-test-static-result-2026-05-20.md
5. 05-git-status-commit-result-2026-05-20.md
6. 06-final-o1-authoring-report-2026-05-20.md (this)

7. Forbidden surface — final attestation

Forbidden	Status
Production mutation	NOT DONE
Live CUT / VERIFY / enact	NOT DONE
Deploy / restart	NOT DONE
Push / tag	NOT DONE
Source_document mutation	NOT DONE
Hardcode secrets / IDs	NOT DONE
StubSigning → real crypto	NOT DONE (O6)
Re-open architecture	NOT NEEDED
FF main without approval	NOT DONE

8. Authorized next macros (sovereign-sequenced)

recommended_next: O2 — UNIT-IMPL + IN-MEMORY E2E (effort xhigh)
  scope:
    - fill the 10 stub phase bodies against the InMemoryDiscoverer
    - implement evaluate_internal predicates (gates.py registry)
    - in-memory dry-run E2E: source_pin → … → closeout on a synthetic doc
    - extend tests to ~400 cases
  authority   : single-line sovereign approval
  duration    : ≤ 1 day

alternatives:
  - PATH_FF_O1_TO_MAIN : trivial FF 0a64a61 → 35ca9e1 to land O1 on main
                          (single-line approval; non-blocking)
  - O2_via_amend       : revise the O1 contracts if a design gap appears
  - defer              : skip to PATH_R3/R4 (orchestrator design alternatives)
                          before continuing O2..O6

9. STOP

This macro halts here. Routing back to GPT / User.

final_outcome : A — ORCHESTRATOR_O1_AUTHORING_PASS
next_action   : STOP → GPT / User