O8F Report 11 — Final O8F report

• macro: v0.6-o8f-implement-f2-f3-gap6-deploy-proof
• date_utc: 2026-05-21 · effort: high · host: Mac (source) + Contabo (deploy/proof)
• FINAL RESULT: A — O8F_IMPLEMENT_DEPLOY_PROOF_PASS

1. Summary

O8F closed the three implementation gaps O8E had left as packages. It ran source work on the Mac SSOT (/Users/nmhuyen/iu-cutter-build/repo/iu-cutter), committed, built a clean artifact, deployed side-by-side to Contabo with the kill-switch OFF, ran the full test suite + real-DB non-mutating proofs, and left zero production mutation.

• F2 — CLOSED: real unit_version body/title now sourced into the discover/cutplan path; placeholder kept only as fallback.
• F3 — CLOSED: new governance_writers.py — generic LegB/Verify recorders driven entirely off per-run live_state, no hard N=60. The v0.5-ratified recorders are left byte-identical, so the M1 writer_digest regression is preserved.
• GAP6 — CLOSED: new compensation.py — a non-mutating per-cut revert planner, append-only Compensation-B builder, soft-revert SQL helper (no hard-delete default), snapshot queries and HOLD bundle.

2. Gate roll-up

Gate	Outcome
G0 precheck-live	PASS — Mac host; repo cad989a clean; VPS v0.6 == O8D; exec_enabled False (R01)
G1 source survey	PASS — paths mapped; patch plan = F2 + F3(new module) + GAP6 (R02)
G2 F2 live-text	PASS — F2 CLOSED; 12 tests; real-DB read-only proof (R03)
G3 F3 generalization	PASS — F3 CLOSED; 27 tests; no hard N=60 in generic path (R04)
G4 GAP6 compensation	PASS — GAP6 CLOSED; 20 tests; non-mutating planner (R05)
G5 local tests/security	PASS — 471/471; no secrets/DSN; no M1 ids in generic path (R06)
G6 commit/artifact	PASS — fdcf580; artifact sha256 23cf94ad…; 88 files (R07)
G7 VPS deploy	PASS — side-by-side promote; v0.4 preserved; no restart (R08)
G8 VPS tests/proofs	PASS — 471/471; 4/4 proofs; DB counts unchanged (R09)
G9 blocker matrix	PASS — F2/F3/GAP6 CLOSED; F1/F4/GAP7/GAP8 + grant audit (R10)
G10 KB reporting	PASS — this 11-doc package

3. What changed

source (Mac):  commit fdcf580 (parent cad989a) — 7 files, +2242 / -16
               M __init__.py · M discover.py · A governance_writers.py
               A compensation.py · A 3 O8F test files
artifact:      iu-cutter-v0.6-fdcf580.tar.gz
               sha256 23cf94ad0fe0416000934f0f837c12f16cd730e2b6f30b5d644541842975f0bc
               221743 bytes · 88 files
VPS:           /opt/incomex/dot/iu-cutter-v0.6 promoted to fdcf580
               backup: iu-cutter-v0.6.pre-o8f-20260521T073219Z
db:            NONE — every proof transaction ROLLED BACK

4. Non-mutation attestation

production_mutation:   NONE — all proof txns rolled back
production_row_counts: unchanged — 158 IU / 165 UV / 60 lifecycle-log;
                       ICX-CONST units 60
execution_enabled:     False — never flipped (Mac source + deployed VPS)
v0.4 skeleton:         untouched — /opt/incomex/dot/iu-cutter HEAD e93424b
                       (e93424b before AND after the promote)
v0.5 ratified files:   ledger_v2_canonical_cut.py / _verify.py byte-identical
                       — M1 writer_digest d99a31d4… preserved
service / cron / docker: none installed / started / restarted
secrets:               none written, none logged
M1 runtime IDs:        absent from the generic path (governance_writers.py /
                       compensation.py)

5. Forbidden-action attestation

Forbidden	Status
Persistent production mutation	NOT DONE — all proof txns rolled back
Enable execution_enabled for a real run	NOT DONE — stays False
Live CUT / VERIFY / enact commit	NOT DONE
Hard delete IU data	NOT DONE — compensation makes soft-revert the default
Delete the v0.4 skeleton	NOT DONE — untouched (e93424b)
Restart a long-running service	NOT DONE
Log secrets	NOT DONE — env values read, never printed
Ask the User for an artifact / secret	NOT DONE
Fake PASS	NOT DONE — F1 PARTIAL + F4/GAP7/GAP8 + grant-audit disclosed
Report-only instead of implementation	NOT DONE — F2/F3/GAP6 closed with code+tests

6. PASS-criteria assessment

precheck_mac_repo_correct:        PASS
o8e_o8d_state_read:               PASS
f2_closed_by_code_and_tests:      PASS — CLOSED
f3_closed_no_hard_n60_generic:    PASS — CLOSED
gap6_closed_runbook_checker:      PASS — CLOSED (planner + helpers)
local_full_tests_pass:            PASS — 471/471
commit_clear:                     PASS — fdcf580
artifact_clean:                   PASS — sha256 23cf94ad…, 88 files
vps_deploy_success:               PASS
execution_enabled_false:          PASS — throughout
vps_tests_pass:                   PASS — 471/471
rollback_only_non_mutating_proof: PASS — 4/4
db_counts_unchanged:              PASS — 158/165/60
kb_reports_uploaded:              PASS — 11 docs

7. State before the first orchestrator-managed production run

CLOSED by O8F:   F2 (live-text), F3 (generic recorders), GAP6 (compensation)
PARTIAL:         F1 — F3 writers exist + leg-B INSERT rollback-only-proven;
                 method-body live commit needs the GAP7 flip
OPEN:            F4 backup key (VPS provisioning),
                 GAP7 sovereign SG_1/SG_2 ruling,
                 GAP8 safe target selection,
                 governance grant audit (cutter_exec/cutter_verify)

8. Recommended next macro

next:  VPS provisioning macro — F4 (BACKUP_GPG_FPR + backup_runner) +
       the cutter_exec/cutter_verify governance grant audit, then
       Mode.DRYRUN a selected GAP8 target.
then:  sovereign GAP7 SG_1 ruling -> first authorised orchestrator-managed
       cut to 'draft' (wire connection_provider + make_governance_writer +
       make_verify_writer; rollback-only first) -> review -> SG_2 enactment.

9. STOP

final_outcome:        A — O8F_IMPLEMENT_DEPLOY_PROOF_PASS
production_mutation:  NONE
execution_enabled:    False (unchanged)
next_action:          STOP -> route to GPT / User