O8 Report 08 — Execution / approval-ready result

• macro: v0.6-o8-production-run-readiness-command-package
• date_utc: 2026-05-21 · host: vmi3080463 (Contabo)
• gates covered: G8 (optional execution) — NOT ENTERED

1. Execution decision

production_run_executed: NO
reason_primary:  GAP-7 — no explicit sovereign approval in KB (Report 07)
reason_blocking: GAP-9 — no live-execution code path exists (Report 01/04)
execution_enabled_flip:  NOT PERFORMED  (state stays False)
mutation_performed:      NONE

G8 is entered only if G7 finds an explicit valid approval and the run is technically possible. Neither holds. G8 is not entered.

2. This is BLOCKED, not merely approval-ready

A pure "approval-ready" outcome (result B) would mean every technical prerequisite is met and only the sovereign signature is missing. That is not the case. Independent of approval, the run is impossible with the deployed artifact:

GAP-9 (decisive) — no production-write code path

The deployed v0.6 is internal milestone O4 "live-dryrun-orchestration". All five mutating phases — pre_write_backup, cut_leg_a, leg_b_record, write_verify, lifecycle_enact — contain only the Mode.DRYRUN simulator path. There is no Mode.LIVE write branch and no live-write discoverer (LiveDryRunDiscoverer: "simulator-only phase bodies … no production write path is reachable").

Flipping __execution_enabled__=True would make Mode.LIVE fall through to the simulator — a run labelled live that writes nothing: a false-PASS hazard, not a production cut.

Closing GAP-9 = a dedicated implementation milestone: a live-write execution adapter + live branches in all 5 phases, wiring the existing v0.5-proven modules (prod_iu_adapter_canonical, ledger_v2_canonical_cut, ledger_v2_canonical_verify, real pg_dump+GPG). That is a substantial, architecture-level change — out of O8's scope and forbidden to author un-reviewed here.

Other open gaps (any one alone blocks O8)

GAP	State
GAP-3 GPG key	OPEN — empty keyring → no real backup
GAP-5 config / /var/lib/cutter	OPEN — not provisioned
GAP-6 per-cut revert tested	OPEN — only DDL-teardown runbook exists
GAP-7 sovereign ruling	OPEN — none in KB
GAP-8 safe target	OPEN — only ICX-CONST registered (forbidden)
GAP-4 governance principal	PARTIAL — roles present, DQ_4 unpinned

3. Result classification

result: C — BLOCKED_WITH_EXACT_O8_GAP
matched_BLOCKED_criteria:
  - "phải redesign architecture lớn"  → GAP-9 (live-execution layer absent)
  - "không có target an toàn"          → GAP-8 (only the Constitution registered)
  - "rollback/backup không đủ"         → GAP-3 + GAP-6
  - "approval không rõ"                → GAP-7 (no O8 ruling, no SG_1/SG_2)
not_result_B: a run is technically impossible, not merely unsigned.
not_result_D: no run was started; nothing to roll back.

4. Forbidden-action attestation

Forbidden	Status
Production mutation w/o approval	NOT DONE
Enable execution_enabled w/o approval	NOT DONE — still False
Live CUT/VERIFY/enact w/o approval	NOT DONE
Delete v0.4 skeleton	NOT DONE
Deploy / restart long-lived service	NOT DONE
Log secrets	NOT DONE — names only
Ask User for artifacts/secrets	NOT DONE
source_document/source_version mutation	NOT DONE
Real crypto replacement	NOT DONE
Fake PASS	NOT DONE — BLOCKED reported honestly

G8 = NOT ENTERED. Result = C (BLOCKED).